ToS Mafia - Day 8 - (3/19) [Town wins!]

was there anything specific that reminded you of his play in other games?

not going to lie the thing where the entire thread has spent the past 800 posts talking nonstop about me is making it kind of hard to unbiasedly read people

i uh, forgot about that tbh (by choice)

back to the null pile he goes

similar levels of FPS play that i remember in SFoL56?57? whichever one wasnt grand idea :upside_down_face:

and i always get a natural leadership vibe from them which i saw when i skimmed candlelight a bit :eyes:

that’s legit

it wasn’t pretty :eyes:

the thing I’m having trouble with with eevee is like

does an eevee who was in JoJo really scumread me for early solviness

specifically looking at the reasoning

but on the other hand I think an eevee who’s groupscum would keep PR hunting in their chat? I was originally reading him as not Witch because he didn’t seem to care about survival but apparently Witch doesn’t need to survive in this setup

I kinda have mixed feelings about this post

like normally my thought would be ā€˜whatever, scumslips are a joke and typoes are a thing’

but then on the other hand this post:

feels like a super fake explanation for how the first one happened

1 Like

I am off to work, I’ll be back when break starts.

ehhhh

i think in context the quote isn’t that awful

1 Like

I kinda want to talk through some people who aren’t named Jake

but the problem is that we don’t really seem to disagree on all that much

and I’m not sure if ā€˜do you think so-and-so is town’ ā€˜yes’ ā€˜cool so do I’ is really going to get anywhere productive

can you explain your reads on the CD people

you know em better than i

͠° ͟ ͟ Ź– ͔°

(ā•¬Ź˜ē›ŠŹ˜ā•¬)

sure

so that’s Darth, Bepwei, and Cheese

Darth I’m still not sure about, I’m hoping to be able to sort her better once she’s able to get online

I’m not sure if there’s really much more I can say about her?

With Bepwei the thing I’ve noticed about CD people is that a lot of them have a really hard time, as scum, calling villagers scum, I checked Bepwei’s most recent scum game and it doesn’t look like he’s an exception

which makes his vote on me townie because he’s not like ā€˜oh huh you could maybe be a slight scumlean possibly but on the other hand it could also come from town but I guess I’ll vote you for now’ (obviously this is hyperbole but you get the idea), like, his post voting me feels like he actually believes in the read

With Cheese the thing that’s kind of pinging me is that he’s voting me and softpushing me but isn’t willing to actually call me a wolf, and he keeps being like ā€˜but it could also be NAI’ every time he talks about me

basically what that feels like to me is that he knows I’m flipping town, and he’s worried that if he’s hardpushing a villager he’ll look scummy, so he’s throwing in a bunch of qualifiers on his read so that he can fall back on ā€˜well I thought they could be town too, let’s go accuse someone who was hardpushing them instead’

whereas I don’t think a town Cheese who actually believes in the push would be doing that, like, that’s not something that makes sense to do from a perspective where you actually expect me to flip scum

1 Like

what is it Marshal :eyes:

alright marshal arete has done a wallpost they must be town

how about your derps read

i don’t think i’ve ever had a good read on him in any game i’ve played with him so i just nullread him all the time :upside_down_face:

there was a bit at the beginning where I asked him to explain why he’d done something and he was like ā€˜no’ and I asked again and he was like ā€˜no but stronger’ and I think if he were scum he comes up with a BS explanation or gets fed one by his scumteam so the fact that he didn’t do that makes me think he’s probably town

also he isn’t pushing any of the people I see as plausible scum and his meta as scum is to relentlessly tunnel his wolfreads for no reason