Umineko FM - Game Over - Mafia Wins


Excuse me, what am I seeing? Your so called town-if-Eli-flips-town wants you dead. Then, could you please die to prove his innocence?

If you flip scum, he is town.
That seems like a fair trade, no?

no problem.

The difference is, youā€™re trying to help Town.

Instead Hippo is hoping on wagon after a wagon.

Yes, thatā€™s my point.

If Surge and Eli were both town, Derps actively pushed away from those wagons, when scum would want to keep the status quo.

iā€™d have to relook but i dont remember anything seriously rivaling those two at eod

@Zone_Q11
I canā€™t quote full context from Derpsā€™s ISO alone, but he actively attempted to create alternatives and persuade others to join him.

Even if Eli is scum I would say itā€™s towny in a vacuum, as his intentions to change the gamestate when scum could easily take the wagon on Surge seem clear.

1 Like

Give me the names of those people. We will LYNCH them in the literal sense of lynching.

I get that the Occult is a sure-fire scum, but my predecessor was afraid it might have some negative after-effects if it were to die.

Should we not play traditionally instead, and hunt for scum who can talk?

How exactly was ā€œstaying on Areteā€™s wagonā€ considered ā€œactively pushing away from Surge vs Eliā€ when Arete subbed in for Surge?

Iā€™m not discussing EoD.

Iā€™m discussing Derpsā€™s attempt to change the wagons prior to EoD.

Youā€™ve been given PoEs from 4 different players.

SFoL63. Not lynching obvious scum is how we lose.

Fuck it.

/vote The Occult

again wasnt there eod but that satrWBERRY COMMENT KINDA LIT. i KNOW HE WENT SOMEWHERE ELSE THO

caps oops

Best Case Scenario: This for some reason lynches The Occult, a guaranteed scum and possibly the person who has them here (Which might explain why everyone is trying to prevent it from being lynched, specifically scummy-esque players).

Medium Case Scenario: We kill a confirmed scum and every shit theyā€™ve done goes back, including cursing Centuries.

Worst Case Scenario: We curse more players.

ya i can see forgettingthat far

ā€¦I donā€™t understand what this post is supposed to say.

i forgot that post ja ja

I canā€™t refute that the attempt to make alternatives is towny. However, I still disbelieve that Derps is town due to the bad first impression I have on him. Unfortunately I am not the type of person who re-evaluate people so easily.

FWIW being in PoE doesnā€™t necessarily mean that you are going to be lynched. It is a pain in the ass to have the discussion constantly revert to a question of trust though. But thatā€™s why I am here: To get you two out from that hellhole.

At worst, I would join the hellhole of PoE and distrust, but if everyone consents scumreading us three together, then that just proves that town always sucks in this forum.

A reasonable choiceā€¦ but sadly I am commiting to voting Derps at the moment.

I canā€™t tell you why Iā€™m Cattailā€™s greatest scumread, only Cattail can do that.

If you donā€™t vote me Iā€™ll give you a cookie

My problem here is people going batshit crazy over my EoD becauseā€¦ Iā€™m not really sure. Because I voted the CW to a person I townread?

u still tr them

Except that you can: Give me your PoE.

Pass. I am committed.