Why
Every time i do this
I go try to confirm or deny my suspicions
And i come out going “oh fuck wait what if im on to something here”
Wowee
btw Do not doc me tonight
I have a 1 shot BPV I can use for myself tonight
Protect Windward at all costs
1 Like
i think appel and night are both fine yeets here but i’d pref appel since night has been townier even if their claim is sus amogus
The push Ghana made on Spak at SoD most likely makes these guys not W/W. I noted that they have no desire to prioritize people in a wide PoE which is annoying and thoughtless at best, and agenda-pushing at worst. With that said, I had a pretty solid townread on them D1, so I wouldn’t immediately jump to the latter. I need to re-evaluate their D1 at some point to see if it still holds up, but right now I still think they’re towny.
I haven’t focused on Spak much either, but I’m getting the same vibes as from Gorta with the way they’re simply commenting on things, there’s so much fluff. The orange zone is basically people I don’t townread, and I can see a world where they’re scum.
PKR’s actions – pushing Seth despite being unsure about their alignment – is meh, but I personally find the tone of this really towny. It’s like… it feels genuine? Especially when handling a slot like Seth. I’m kind of sheeping Chloe/Marl’s read on this tbh
I noticed Wind making lots of comments like these, and while I understand that some of them may be jokes, the consistency with them is a bit unsettling. Wind and Seth are most likely not W/W
People push me for trying to shoot Derps, and he proceeds to defend my mindset and push me in spite of that.
Like, my mindset isn’t “If they’re town, they’ll shoot someone in the PoE and that’s good”
It’s more about the fact that they were the only one seeing reasons why that shot would not be beneficial to wolves, but he goes and calls me a wolf anyway for the rest of the day. Literally the only thing he has going on for him is breadcrumbing his claim once in a joke, and that’s probably where I should remind people of this:
If that’s your thought process, why would I need to clear myself after casing Gorta when people were looking for an alternative cuddle? There’d be no point in that.
I believe Min is town, but this is something to be noted
Imagine W/W/W wagons D1 
Light, you’re forgetting the fact that you yourself ignored your own read on me for the whole day.
This is why I can see a Wolf!Light world, because some of his thought processes make no sense whatsoever
There’s so much info around him it’s a pain to sort it out
Wind’s actions here are hard to read, because… she is genuinely questioning people, yes? But I can’t help but think that it’s a pocket attempt because everyone else was locking me as scum without a second thought, especially when they go around it in this roundabout way of asking questions instead of actually giving their own takes, which would make it easy for them to back out later and still look good
I was reminded of this interaction, and Chloe/Gorta are never W/W. Ever.
Wind seems to be the only one with seemingly anti-consensus takes, with her suspecting Seth for his actions and soft-defending me. I feel like… the general concept of having them is rand >V? But the context here makes it really difficult. I saw a few wallposts and good takes from them, but… meh?
@Chloe why do you townread Wind?
I don’t want to OMGUS
But Derps is blatantly openwolfing and you can’t tell me otherwise
Despite YBW/Gorta interactions, the way they jump on my wagon without ever giving some thoughts of their own about the situation or people’s alignments makes this really opportunistic
I feel iffy about making reads based on my own wagonomics, but it is what it is
Eli’s tone here seems considerably different from what I’ve seen from his scum games. He feels comfortable in the thread. Therefore Eli is town, though I believe they claimed IC already so this is bleh
It was actually before! That was the most awesome coincidence ever, haha~ I happened to scroll down to it and was like “hey, redwood trees are cool”
Where do Marl & Light stand in your list, then?
Overall Min has been villagery with their tone and thought process I can easily get behind. I think some of their votes have been iffy, but I also saw the same behavior in Pokemon 9er
Essentially, I’m still treating them as a new-ish player
And so forms my readlist
Marl is annoying, therefore lockscum
2 Likes
I have a tinfoil concerning Eli that I think maybe Light also hinted at
And if it’s true, Eli never dies at night
2 Likes
rip chloe
I’m actually pretty comfortable hanging in PoE as long as I don’t die
I don’t wanna claim yet