Ayyy, Chloe coming in hot with the useful questions!
Mine was Seth’s game w/ YouButWorse, and I learned that it’s important to keep your ideas consistent in-thread as scum. There was one post pretty early D1 where I asked in-thread if a scum stall shot was possible (it was open setup and Town was using RB as info), and then stalled a shot later to frame someone else. Nobody called me out on it, but it would’ve looked super suspicious on an ISO.
I’d say it depends. Coasting as scum is super easy, and there’s a point at which you have to ask if you’d wanna bring that person into LyLo. Optimally we’d have replacements for inactive slots, but that’s not always viable.
+1; I take forever to type stuff out because I read and re-read my posts, so having a “replying…” prompt freaks me out lol.
Min: Comfortable in thread and I don’t have a problem with their takes so far.
This for example I can get behind.
Hmm I agree with the first two, though Marl I’m not sure about yet.
I just want to be lazy and say "He’s top poster so by SBPCBWE he’s town, though he doesn’t fit that pattern ala EFoL 4.75.
That’s something I agree with.
I can get behind an Appel is town world.
Perhaps I’m dumb for saying that min is pretty much confirmed town in my eyes for mindmelding on my Chloe read, though that’s something I’m going with today.
I dont have any takes that im comfortable sharing
I personally think seth’s weird attitude is towny
but
the last time i thought that he was scum reeeee
I don’t agree with this, but can’t think of any incentive for scum to come out of the gate swinging like this without justification (especially w/ a popular slot like Chloe). Best guess is RVS so Light could gauge Chloe’s response, to which she didn’t really show much concern lol.
I’ll level it with you ClonedCheese. If you’re town, you should be fine with making takes even if they might be proven wrong with more information as the game progresses.
As I said before, if you’re town the onus is on you to prove to us that you’re town so we don’t have to eliminate you at day or vig you at night to resolve your slot.
You really gonna make me get my glasses for this lol
Ayyy high five, that’s the person I framed with the stalled NK last game lol
Not knowing any of your history, he’s either:
Trying to come out the gate as against you because it’s what most people would think scum wouldn’t do (scum!Light)
Trying so hard to avoid getting pocketed that he’s started a random tunnel (town!Light)
It’s not a RVS bait like I thought it was because Light’s doubling down so hard. After reading through a bit more I’m starting to lean more toward the first option, but still don’t have nearly enough info (or context on Chloe/Light games) to say definitively.