Vanilla Townies - Are they still despised?

You can always add 2 vanillarizers and more prs or something lol.

Make everyone vanillarizer

What if there was a game where everyone was vanilla, but town had a passive where at the end of every night one town member randomly dies

That would be swingy since based much on RNG

True.

that has been done before by proxy

1 Like

hell I hosted that technically

1 Like

Funnily enough I’ve been talking to Geyde about hosting a game with Vanilla Towns included

Coming Soon

btw any of ya’ll who voted “NEVER PLAY GAME WHERE I CAN RAND VT” better have a damned good explanation for why you don’t just compulsively dislike it because you like pushing buttons

Well, I stick with my ancient reasoning

They dont like playing VT

Hey just gonna throw my opinion in. Vanilla townies are fine, they are a change of pace, because usually everyone has an abilitiies and no abilities are fun sometimes. Now the problem I have with them is when one of two things happen. There is nothing to supplement the VT experience like ITAs, Mechanics, or Events. So its only voting and talking. At this point you are only there to make reads and vote. This can get really dull in some case and really dampen the mood of the game imo. Like Im not the best read maker so when its all I can do, I kinda like I feel even more pointless. The other problem is when one side feels heavily out weighed in abilities compared to another. So like if its only VTs against a stacked team of wolves with like 2 or so abilities each. Like VT townies can be fine but mechanics need to be there for fun and it needs to be that the wolf team isnt stacked compared to them.

I’d argue just making reads is far more fun than just pushing buttons
but that’s just me

Not every PR has to be invest

Also you can just make mountainous wich is Good too

Jailkeeper is the greatest role in all of mafia

Problem is when youre VT And others have interesting powers

VT when ITAs exist is commonly seen as still “very fun”

Therefore if the mechanics are interesting the likelihood of player retention should be high

No

However there are several players with a severe annoyance toward playing VT regardless of mechanics.