back to the Eli thing, I was a bit more inclined to agree with Aelin off personal experience, even though I know she misread Eli once in a recent game. I had about the same reasoning for my townread on him as she did here, though, so that’s really why I thought her read had more merit.
on the other hand, January also has experience with Eli so I’m taking that into account, too. I also feel like Eli sort of dipped after January revealed that they are Atlas, and I’m not sure if it was just coincidental or if Eli actually was trying to avoid getting scumread while he was still majority townread.