I still think Clownzu could just be a wolf posting well for her first game. She hasn’t really taken strong stances at any point, nor has she been forced to do so. I’m the only person who’s really suspicious of her and nobody’s supporting me on this, so all she has to do is keep up what she’s already done if she’s a wolf here. And that’s kinda what she’s been doing? She’s remained static thus far.
If I didn’t think that then I would’ve just outright said it by now. On day 1, probably. I saw their minus post and I was instantly like “yeah, this is always town, thanks.”
Had an entrance string of posts that was super solvy by his standards and thus super villagery for him, to the point that I was highly confident in him being town and so were my village reads.
Right now he’s been dropping a bit but that start of his still seems out of wolfrange.
For the third time: I just want to hear more from Pigeon. If he really is a LHF, then he should’ve tried his best to not become one e.g. by talking more, because I haven’t heard anything towny from that slot.
I’ve been trying to push her for a while now and I’ve continuously garnered zero support on this, which is frankly pretty annoying. Marl was like “why am I not seeing what you’re seeing” and this honestly works in reverse well, I’m not really seeing what’s villagery. I did have a vague townread there on day 1, but in hindsight it was given for nebulous “new player, probably a villager, there is some independent thought in there” reasons. I don’t actually think she’s been villagery anymore, I think she’s done a decent job conducting her mini-investigations in the thread through questioning but she hasn’t really drawn strong conclusions or taken strong stances. That sorely missing from her ISO, coupled with the fact we almost certainly had V/V wagons last EoD, makes me think she’s just mafia going through the motions and relying on tone to carry her through the day (which it has so far, if she is W! Nobody seems to take issue with her other than me).
So here’s potential wagons today, as far as I’m seeing.
Whysper (most likely dying)
Someone we make clown a wagon
Marl… rarely, probably not happening
Pigeon, for some reason
Zone