I mean, yeah… That’s like the only other thing I have on them that doesn’t rely on meta or trusting someone who knows their meta. Since the other part of my read comes from assuming that both Marl and Vulgard are forced to read City off of meta regardless of their alignments unless they are exactly all wolves together, which I’m not really seeing right now.
have I listened to him much at all this game? no
he also isn’t constantly inaccurate all the time its something that changes all the time lol
I haven’t been sheeping him. On D1 when he said to either vote Leafia or declare ourselves his enemy, I chose not to vote Leafia and to declare myself his enemy even though I townread him.
I only wanted to push Silviu.and D2 I forced the Whysper yeet, not Marl,and not anyone else.
Couldn’t you have t!marl, t!vul, and w!city?
Just because they both have meta reads doesn’t mean they have to be accurate meta reads.
It’s based more on his tone than on his accuracy, if I’m understanding correctly?
Yeah, it’s absolutely possible. I only said that both of them are forced to meta read City, not that City could never change up their meta. I don’t know enough to give an opinion on that but I’m saying that I currently see their play as something that can come from town, similar to certain other players I have seen as town, and it is not objectively scummy to me because there’s no agenda and no shade.
1 Like
On Marl? I would like to say that I yeeted him in the first two wolf games he had when he came back from his break here, and I’d never played with him before. So I’ve seen him wolf and I’ve also caught him for it.
I will not say that I actually believe his play here is completely out of his wolf range, but it is very near what I’d consider villagery in 95% of cases.
question
if we think city is distancing from marl
why are we concerned about killing city more than killing marl
Never before his break, I mean
First game I was in with him he was a wolf and agenda pushed me and I managed to get the wagon off me and onto him
Not everyone reads both of them as scum - some people are willing to vote city but not marl iirc
1 Like
If they’re both mafia, Marl is always a goon because he offered to suicide over Leafia, and City is the roleblocker.
Idk what I believe right now but if they’re w/w I never see Marl as roleblocker.
im just curious
since city would be implicated from marl’s alignment and not necessarily the other way around, so wanted to understand what the reasoning was
this makes sense
1 Like