[VFM] JoaT^2 - (6/15) - šŸ˜¹ Pirates (Town) Win!

The only reason you arenā€™t scumreading me right now is because you have TMI that Iā€™m town and donā€™t want to look bad if I get yeeted because Iā€™ll flip town.

Okay, so let me try and break this scenario down:

Io is pushing Sulit and it had some wagon support

You/Gorta are wagons too with Gorta being bigger and from your PoV, these are both wagons on town.

Io is townreading both you and Gorta.

You are townleaning Io

Why should Scum version of Io suddenly scumread you now in this situation and change their lynch target from Sulit to you?

It would look opportunistic and possibly antagonize your wavering townlean into a scumlean unto them, because youā€™re quite a notorious OMGUSer. You also had less wagon support than Gorta, so it would be a more difficult lynch, which they were already pushing unto Sulit. Keeping the wagons the same would be perfect for them, because they look ā€œrightā€ and pushing ā€œthe real scumā€ instead of being on the wagon that hit town.

I already explained this point three times now. Scumreading me D3 would be the perfect play for them due to how I was acting and admittedly, after Gortaā€™s flip, I likely wouldā€™ve understood why they were scumreading me today if they had been doing so. Youā€™re not going to fool me into thinking Io could be scum here so please stop trying. Especially when you keep using the same argument over and over worded differently each time.

And fmpov, Gortaā€™s wagon wasnā€™t on a villager because I thought Gorta was scum.

It would also have been easy to mislynch me today and get away with it once Gorta flipped town.

WHYYY

I just gave you a whole paragraph on why that wouldnā€™t be optimalā€¦

I am not trying to convince you that they are scum here, but I am trying to ascertain your logic. I would be disproving your townread on them, not proving a scumread on them.

That doesnā€™t matter, at this point we know that wagon was on townā€¦

Thatā€™s just it. It would be optimal. It would be the best possible play for scum!Io to make. Continuing to townread me and continuing the push on Sulit and you would be the stupidest play ever for scum!Io to make.

Why is it it not equally easy for scum Io to mislynch me here, since I was a driving force on Gortaā€™s wagon too?

It does matter because if I thought he was town, I wouldnā€™t have pushed on him at all.

Because? This is just saying itā€™s optimal in three different way, not why it is optimal.

Because I was the strongest pusher on him and a lot of people were flipfloppy on my slot.

It doesnā€™t matter for the argument I am presenting that Io did not need to change the wagons, because a town already had the top wagon.

I already explained why it was optimal.

Can you quote it?

It does matter what I thought Gorta was because in a t!Leafia world, why would I be pushing a townread of mine? Youā€™re only trying to discredit me right now.

Iā€™ll do better than that. Iā€™ll quote very time I explained why it was optimal. Because Iā€™ve done so more than once here.

1 Like

This is unrelated to any of these questions. I am trying to explain why your Io townread argument is flawed. I am not even talking about you here reallyā€¦ more so a scum Io perspective and who they would push.

These are in reverse order by the way.

Second to last explanation here.

Hmmm, there werenā€™t as many times as I thought there were honestly.

This is still not explaining this to meā€¦