[VFM] Poisonous Mafia - (3/17) - Completed

UNOFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Accused Voters Votes
Emilia PoisonedSquid 1/7
Arete Napoleon 1/7
Hippolytus SirDerpsALot, Italy 2/7
Italy Arete, Marshal, Hippolytus, CRichard564, Vulgard 5/7

L-2 on Italy as of now.

Fun fact about Derps, guys.

Consider that Amelia and eevee flipped Mafia Goon. Which means, they were not the wolf PRs.

Now look at day 1 again. If Derps is a wolf, it means his buddies wanted to lynch him over Ameliaā€¦ despite the fact heā€™s a PR, and Amelia isnā€™t.

If Derps had been the poisoner, that wouldnā€™t have been as bad, but itā€™s still strange.

1 Like

I wouldnā€™t write it off as ā€œimpossible,ā€ just ā€œunlikely.ā€ Wolves generally want to keep their PRs alive, especially if they are losing.

+1

Seriously, Derps just is never a wolf this game.

Oh, and by the way, I asked the hosts if the mafia rolecop could find the Town Backup Poisoner. The answer is no.
Which means that leaving cover is still good.

ā€¦Iā€™m not sure what I meant by the last statement.
Anyhow, Iā€™m pretty sure you guys need to look at Hippo again regardless of Italyā€™s flip. It looks Italy has mostly resigned themselves to being lynched, and thatā€™s NAGL. Could come from a villager (and thatā€™s why I advocated for poisoning this slot instead), but could also come from a wolf. On this point we kinda have to lynch him sooner or later, unless we want to deal with this slot in LyLo (which might be a nightmare).

1 Like

the backup poisoner doesnā€™t know theyā€™re a backup so leaving backup cover seems counterproductive

ā€¦

1 Like

can we blame the fact that Iā€™m apparently illiterate on it being 3:30 AM

1 Like

If youā€™re a villager in the PoE, work to clear yourself instead of resigning yourself to the noose.

1 Like

Let me know when you are ready to die and then we can hammer :slight_smile:

@PoisonedSquid

Before you die, explain why you suspect Emilia

I think we can hammer anytime, honestly. I doubt we will get more from Italyā€™s slot if they intend to remain near-useless like this.

Eh should I get squid to answer my question first?

Sure.

1 Like

By the way, I stand by the assertion that Town Poisoner should probably target in Hippo/Emilia/CRich

I would go Hippo

Not me

Why not?

Because I am town