[VFM] Poisonous Mafia - (3/17) - Completed

i TR hippo more for what he was doing initially and i think italy has been kind of scummy and his reaction to my reaction to your towntell thing did not feel genuine

2 Likes

Like he always goes off about how he cannot be read off of his ever-changing meta

but i would expect him to deny the ā€œtowntellā€ off of this logic
but instead he didnā€™t, and i was so sure that he would that it threw me off. It seems he valued the towncred more over his general FM values which, in the position that scum are in right now, makes me feel like scum!italy is a viable world.

This is who I think is town from VCA and not including anyone dying today from lynch or poison.

Town I donā€™t doubt.
Arete
Marshal
Napoleon
Alice
SirDerpsAlot

Town not entirely sure of.
sulit
Emilia

These are my strongest mafia reads.
Italy if he doesnā€™t get lynched.
Hippo same as Italy though if Italy is lynched and flips Mafia, then Iā€™ll rethink my mafia read on Hippo.

How so?

Also, I sense village complacency. Please donā€™t get complacent after this EoD too.

Itā€™s somewhat ā€œfineā€ to be complacent now, but definitely not tomorrow, especially if a wolf doesnā€™t die.

Well Alice wasnā€™t poisoned which indicates that Mafia did not believe Aliceā€™s TP claim.

If thatā€™s the case, you could expect all Mafiosi to think like that.

Eevee was originally on Derpsā€™ wagon and switched to Amelia when everyone else did. So I donā€™t think Eevee was trying to save him and more like mislynch him.

I feel like this is a weak reason to think of what Richard said as a townslip.
There are many reasons why Alice might not have been poisoned. I saw her claim as a bluff, too.

I intentionally wrote that post about ā€œguys please donā€™t talk about Aliceā€™s claim itā€™s badā€ so that mafia would bite it.

1 Like

Emilia is locktown again to me.

1 Like

Trust me I wonā€™t get complacent

i do townread quite a good chunk of the game and have varying degrees of townlean on another chunk and so iā€™m feeling safe

but never complacent

Eh youā€™re right.

Though ā€¦ Alice did rescind her claim but CRichard still believes it.

I guess if anything CRichard didnā€™t read SoD D3.

I think Hippo has a point here. Ameliaā€™s reaction then wasnā€™t that she was being voted by a wolfbuddy. Looks like she was genuinely surprised to Hippoā€™s vote on them.

Iā€™ve recently been in a game where I was the only villager active during LyLo, which means village complacency is always going to bother me.

Or heā€™s just confused. The idea of claiming and rescinding and fakeclaiming as a villager must be rather shocking to a player coming from ToL.

The easy world is Squid/Italy

I donā€™t know if I believe itā€™s that easy but that is in fact a viable world

Has Squid done anything notable after the first couple hours of today

Eevee voted Amelia, but it was only done because she was going to be the lynch anyway and he didnā€™t want to seem suspicious. You need to see the circumstances behind a vote rather than just if someone votes or not.

3 Likes

Yes and for good reason. BD/Villagers/Town who fake claim cause chaos in town discussions. Town doesnā€™t want chaos from fake claiming townies. Scum on the other hand do want chaos.

she has done basically nada all day