[VFM] Poisonous Mafia - (3/17) - Completed

UNOFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Accused Voters Votes
Emilia PoisonedSquid 1/7
Arete Napoleon 1/7
Hippolytus SirDerpsALot, Italy 2/7
Italy Arete, Marshal, Hippolytus, CRichard564, Vulgard 5/7

L-2 on Italy as of now.

Fun fact about Derps, guys.

Consider that Amelia and eevee flipped Mafia Goon. Which means, they were not the wolf PRs.

Now look at day 1 again. If Derps is a wolf, it means his buddies wanted to lynch him over Amelia… despite the fact he’s a PR, and Amelia isn’t.

If Derps had been the poisoner, that wouldn’t have been as bad, but it’s still strange.

1 Like

I wouldn’t write it off as ā€œimpossible,ā€ just ā€œunlikely.ā€ Wolves generally want to keep their PRs alive, especially if they are losing.

+1

Seriously, Derps just is never a wolf this game.

Oh, and by the way, I asked the hosts if the mafia rolecop could find the Town Backup Poisoner. The answer is no.
Which means that leaving cover is still good.

…I’m not sure what I meant by the last statement.
Anyhow, I’m pretty sure you guys need to look at Hippo again regardless of Italy’s flip. It looks Italy has mostly resigned themselves to being lynched, and that’s NAGL. Could come from a villager (and that’s why I advocated for poisoning this slot instead), but could also come from a wolf. On this point we kinda have to lynch him sooner or later, unless we want to deal with this slot in LyLo (which might be a nightmare).

1 Like

the backup poisoner doesn’t know they’re a backup so leaving backup cover seems counterproductive

…

1 Like

can we blame the fact that I’m apparently illiterate on it being 3:30 AM

1 Like

If you’re a villager in the PoE, work to clear yourself instead of resigning yourself to the noose.

1 Like

Let me know when you are ready to die and then we can hammer :slight_smile:

@PoisonedSquid

Before you die, explain why you suspect Emilia

I think we can hammer anytime, honestly. I doubt we will get more from Italy’s slot if they intend to remain near-useless like this.

Eh should I get squid to answer my question first?

Sure.

1 Like

By the way, I stand by the assertion that Town Poisoner should probably target in Hippo/Emilia/CRich

I would go Hippo

Not me

Why not?

Because I am town