[VFM] Poisonous Mafia - (3/17) - Completed

hmm this sits the wrong way with me as well

not because he opposed the derps wagon but because he didn’t really vote to back it up i beleive

…is it just me, or is CRich’s perspective here inconsistent in a way that indicates he’s TMIing himself as Mafia?

Yeah, I don’t get his perspective at all. Rn I’m for lynching him and then poisoning/lynching Hippo and Emilia.

1 Like

well to be fair his perspective was ‘D1 lynches are more likely to flip town in full generality’

yeah

if I think Marshal is a villager

and I trust your read on Derps

and you/soolit are V/V

and Hippo/Emilia aren’t W/W

then this should lock the game

I think

Crich just seems so different from other games

like in Sfol58 he was kinda normal with his thought process

i don’t think he had much weird perspective

this game it’s really hard to see where his posts and actions actually come from in a logical perspective.

@CRichard564 what, generally, was your approach to the game coming in

That it would be an interesting twist on forum Mafia with poisoners for both sides.
Poison is similar to bleed in ToL, so there is a common thread here and with ToL.

but like remove mechanics

how did you want to play this game coming in

it can be as simple as “just like always” but an answer is what i need to try to understand your thought process

That we have town cop find mafia. They get lynched and they flip mafia and finding the rest of the Mafia is only a matter of finding who didn’t vote up Mafia.

Remove mechanics
don’t think of them.

How, socially, did you want to play this game.

Same as ToL.

So would you say your social approach to this game was the same you wanted to take in Last Stand of the Virtuous

Yes as that was my first SFoL game here.

I just find the contrast between games to be sharp.

You handled pressure much more normally there and here you are throwing a lot more shade.

@Arete complete and total shot in the dark, but do you happen to remember ToL games with Crich and how he played there as BD and as nontown.

I’m not sure I ever played ToL with Arete.

eh it was kind of a long shot i’m just doing everything i can to understand your perspective because i feel it’s how we solve your slot

Emilia and Hippo get into a really dumb conversation about PRs

(these are part of the above but I’m highlighting them since none of you are going to read the dropdown anyway and this just … doesn’t feel like a conversation involving two wolves)

Emilia and Hippo get into a really dumb argument about meta (this one is the only one in this post even plausibly ever W/W)

this interaction is the most revealing in my opinion

I don’t see this exchange ever involving two wolves

I don’t remember ever seeing him in ToL although to be fair I don’t remember everyone I play with

This conversation is why I don’t think we’re seeing two Mafia arguing with each other. It most likely is a Town/Mafia argument. If it is a Town/Mafia argument, the big question is who is town and who is mafia?