[VFM] Poisonous Mafia - (3/17) - Completed

Forum Matches Completed
#2734

Why Squid

#2735

Technically I should be working on school right now but ehhhh

#2736

Because they seemed scummy (I voted them earlier I cant remember why but I had a good reason to)

#2737

@Hippolytus Imo Dat isn’t in their scum meta

#2738

Hippo still V for this take.

I still think Squid is V
Why are you tunnelling Derps? Don’t you think their posts could’ve been V-motivated?

#2739

Here’s my thoughts, for those who are interested;
https://forum.imperium42.com/t/vfm-poisonous-mafia-17-17-day-1-apples-to-apples/80690/1844?u=appelsiini
https://forum.imperium42.com/t/vfm-poisonous-mafia-17-17-day-1-apples-to-apples/80690/1850?u=appelsiini
First of all, I agree that Vul and Marshal are definitely town. Arete is trustworthy, but I’m not sure if the whole thing with them ignoring the accusations got resolved. Will have to re-read later. Sulit and Nap seem alright for now. This is time consuming, so I won’t go into details about everybody.

I don’t necessarily think Amelia’s a wolf. As sulit pointed out already, there is little resistance to the wagon, and their read of the whole situation was quite helpful, although they don’t necessarily provide much new information. These two messages were the only thing that got me really thinking, but other than that, there isn’t much that seems off.
https://forum.imperium42.com/t/vfm-poisonous-mafia-17-17-day-1-apples-to-apples/80690/2373?u=appelsiini
https://forum.imperium42.com/t/vfm-poisonous-mafia-17-17-day-1-apples-to-apples/80690/2327?u=appelsiini

For the most part, Rich seems town to me. They’re quite aggressive, but they have lots of reasoning behind their actions and give a villager-ish feel, albeit I don’t like trying to predict how mafia/healer will act because that’ll just give both factions ideas even if it’s not necessarily a wolfy thing to say.

As for who I suspect the most, those would probably be some of the other nulls (Eevee, Andrej). I’m kind of put off by Alice’s attitude, but I feel like that’s just my personal thoughts interfering so I’ll have to re-read their posts again at some point. I have no opinion about the others yet.

Poisonous FM - Mafia Chat
#2740

I like this post a lot ngl

1 Like
#2741

I thought they were new to FM, or is it just the site

#2742

V reaction from Derps
Why would a wolf give a damn
Reads like someone genuinely surprised/impressed
Hippo stop tunneling Derps

i’m totally not willaging

#2743

I am new to FM, but I’ve been lurking a lot and I think I’ve gotten the hang of how this works. Everyone’s reads are valuable

1 Like
#2744

Gotta say I’m impressed, took me a game or two to realise what half the stuff you just mentioned even was

1 Like
#2745

I disagree

#2746

I like the post as well, why don’t you?

#2747

I don’t know

Something seems really off here

#2748

Idk

I know they’re new but most of the thoughts were already stated elsewhere and it’s weird they know this much already

#2749

I had a second where I thought maybe they were wolf being coached but that would be an ehhhh play. Coaching someone new to say something like this isn’t something I see scum doing

#2750

My first 1-2 games I just sheeped others reasoning, do you think it’s scum AI?

#2751

Like following by all the people were assuming are town the team is

  1. eevee
  2. Andrej
  3. PoisonedSquid
  4. Italy
  5. Amelia

Somewhere in here

And that doesn’t sit right with me

Remove Italy and it’s exactly Eevee, Squid, Amelia, and Andrej.

I need to remove people again jsut to be sure because tf

#2752

I don’t think everyone has the same reads though

1 Like
#2753

At first I thought about staying silent precisely because I have no new information, but came to a conclusion that it’s easier to read a person who says their thoughts out loud than a null. I guess all I have to say is that I hope I can make you trust me later on.