I’m rather happy with Darth’s recent answer if I’m being honest.
Their posts at EoD yesterday line up with someone who viewed my slot and Mole as W/W, and their consistency in this is hard to fake as a wolf.
darth_tabor:
Reread moleland and they feel like a scumlean instead of a neutral. They haven’t really contributed much, only to make their random opening (still unexplained but assumed RVS) vote and take a neutral stance on anyone else’s opinion. It seems like they don’t have much of their own opinions and are just contradicting others.
Depending on their response to my reads post, I might put them as more of a scumlean than you, but we’ll see.
Thie is before Moleland placed a vote on Wazza. It’s an individual wolfread, free of association. (As in, they weren’t grouping Mole with me at the time)
Then we get into the mindset change, where they view me/Mole as potential W/W, based on his vote.
darth_tabor:
I’m still not sure if you’re higher than Anagram for me yet, you have barely any reads and this reasoning is weak at best. It’s omgus but if you wanted to protect yourself, I would think you’d go for one of the wagons instead.
Ughhhhhh I’m gonna have to reread both of you now
This implies darth thinks there is a reason he didn’t go for one of the main wagons (me/Raven).
Mole then moves onto Raven, with a naked vote and no progression. (I even pointed out this terrible progression here and it contributed to me voting Mole). This is a roundabout way of saying “does anybody else think Mole might be trying to save Anagram here?”
darth_tabor:
You stated that they are posting more than their inactivity in the first 24 hours, but you do realize that the things they post now still do not contribute to scum hunting? There’s no attempt on their part to look for scum, they are just voting Raven because it seems convenient.
If that’s not scummy I don’t know what is
More hints of their thought-process that Mole and I could be W/W and hes trying to save my ass with an opportunistic vote on Raven.
It was slightly weird to me that they viewed Mole as scummier than us if they viewed us as potentially W/W. But at the same time its a good look that they don’t just group us together and they still have a focus on individual reads.
darth_tabor:
You say that, but it doesn’t really make sense? At this point there’s not any real case for Moleland being town, but you refuse to vote them because they won’t get lynched? With the current 3 way tie, just 3 votes on Moleland could easily shift the vote count. I know I would rather have Moleland out than the others on the table, and Anagram stated they would be willing to switch if more people were on board, which I understand since they’re on the chopping block right now
Your case for not voting Moleland at this point is weak at best
This looks like a W/W/W read with Wazza now being in the group with me and Mole? Their thought-process on me/Mole is consistent.
Now for the fun shit
The CFD
We vote Mole
Darth votes Mole over us, when we absolutely coulda been the lynch there since our vote was removed from Raven.
Here’s the VC shift, with top wagons being red:
Before CFD
clonedcheese:
VC
Voted
Voters
Votes
Raven
Yawn, Anagram, Moleland, zone_Q11
4/5
Anagram
Raven, Trivial, darth_tabor
3/5
Zone
Wazza, gorta
2/5
After we vote Moleland
clonedcheese:
VC
Voted
Voters
Votes
Raven
Yawn, Moleland, zone_Q11
3/5
Anagram
Raven, Trivial, darth_tabor
3/5
Zone
Wazza, gorta
2/5
Mole
Anagram
1/5
At this point, there are now two wagons tied for top. Us (who we have TMI as being town), and Raven (who could be scum).
So the question is, why Mole over us? We know Mole isn’t a wolf, now. So here are some scenarios:
Raven/Anagram/Mole are V/V/V
In this scenario, Darth voted Mole as a genuine scumread of theirs, and Darth is a villager.
or
Darth is a wolf who decided to push LHF. This is the less likely of the two, as it would be much easier to just stay on us, or move to Raven for a 4/5 wagon, and have a guaranteed townie death here. They coulda sat pretty on our wagon.
Raven/Anagram/Mole are W/V/V
Scenario one includes a town Darth, who voted Mole as a genuine scumread of theirs.
Scenario two has Darth as a wolf with Raven. In this case, Darth moved off of a top wagon and onto a wagon with a single vote, leaving their scumbud as top wagon with 3 votes. Thats dangerous. All they have to do is get a single vote on us and bam, we die there instead of Raven.
The only real world I see w!darth is a world with w!raven, but even then it just… makes so much more sense for darth to be a villager here.
This response fits so perfectly into the narrative of v!darth who genuinely believed I could have been w/w with Mole and Mole was trying to save my ass yesterday.
Its so hard to fake this view as a wolf and stay consistent with it throughout the chaos of an EoD and the madness that is a CFD, and I’m pretty much ready to put darth into my towncore.
I am fine with a darth vote today, but I won’t be voting for quite some time because I’d rather people not sheep votes, and actually attempt to do solving of their own.
~ Player 1