also
what
i said they’re not w/w specifically, i don’t see how that equates to saying they’re v/w
ok the fact that this is the fifth time that I’ve corrected this (I said this about literally one specific post) and you’re still pushing this argument means there’s no way I actually believe you’re arguing in good faith
just no.
oh
oh my god
are you actually saying that after the game was randed I literally just decided you were a wolf
and this is somehow wolfy behaviour from me?
this is literally ridiculous what the fuck
Did I box in proph on day 1
why is that a “what”
i’m trying to solve their slots because that’s the part of the game i happened to read and actually pay attention to
As far as I can tell almost all of Proph’s arguments against me are basically just repeating things he’s heard me said while avoiding the big picture of what I’m actually arguing for, most likely because it’s a lot easier to discredit me if he did that rather than actually tackling why he thinks I’m a wolf because its a lot harder to actually discredit my entire case than to just take one paragraph I posted a day ago and pretend that’s my entire case and argue against that.
And also his reason for shading me is patently ridiculous and literally makes no sense at all
yeah no this man’s just wolfing
that question had literally no relevance to what i was poking at you for
i’m not saying you have to know they are villagers
i’m saying it’s wolfy if they are because you said they are probably v/w without saying which, and then backtracked to saying they could be v/v
I literally said in that post that Vulgard was townier
the only reason I put a caveat that they could be v/v is because I know I’ve pretty consistently misread both of them, but I don’t think their cases on each other looked partnered from that bit of the thread. I’ll read them more in-depth as individual slots but I think Proph might be wolfing, I just don’t want to confbias myself on his slot like I did in ciconia without considering that I could still be wrong.
why does vulgard’s play remind you of yourself in ciconia
the difference between you in that game and him in this one is that your motivation was clear at an earlier stage and you made more of a visible attempt to analyse responses to it. vulgard isn’t, really
1 Like
it’s moreso the talk surrounding his play and not the play itself that reminds me of ciconia tbh
because i saw a lot of commentary about vulgard’s first few posts being wolfy but the way the thread handled it was kinda jumpy iirc
tbf i was half asleep when i read that part of the thread so maybe i should reread it
Because you made it sound like you expected him to be wolfy from the very beginning of the game. Although this interaction I’s giving you a somewhat more villagery feel, so I might be wrong on you being a wolf. Your confusion over this just sounds villagery, and not like a wolf trying to backtrack from accidentally outing. /unvote
I read some stuff but i think my brain is mush soup again because i honestly can’t focus
might just come back in the morning and power through some backreading
has anyone taken GGhana’s takes seriously yet? why does it sound like you’re trying to shut down what he said? sorry if I didn’t read enough to know the answer to this, but I’m curious.
Partial mindmeld with me, especially with the first part. GGhana has moved up to only being a scumlean for me honestly.