I think both sulit and I enjoy playing with Kat enough to protest against fear killing them
Votecount
| Voted | Voters | Count |
|---|---|---|
| willtaylor | Leafia, Alice, Marluxion | 3/6 |
| Emilia | willtaylor, EliThePsycho | 2/6 |
| Prophylaxis | Sulit | 1/6 |
| Wisp | Prophylaxis | 1/6 |
| Not Voting | Arctic, Emilia, Wisp, staypositivefriend | 4 |
Majority is 6. Day ends at 2021-09-02T20:00:00Z
Marluxion think about this post, at least from the PoV of Sulit
reread it a few times, and think about the timing of events, please
1 Like
Eliās opening wasnāt great, the roleplaying comes off as forced
I did like his comment on this
feeling forced, but then he kinda just unvotes it, with very little progression
Votes Chloe which pretty much amounts to OMGUS, then again, randomly re-evaluates it and unvotes again
then proceeds to do a quote wall. which leads to mostly negative conclusions, but says they are not going to vote there, which is ???. and even the stuff he does like, like āthis section is goodā, even though all Chloe said, āYou Wolfin Broā. I just donāt really see it as a consistent progression.
As their posts go on, they seem to be a little lost
Sheeps Gghana
Casts doubt on Marlās thoughts on Proph, but doesnāt really have any progression there. He doesnāt really explain the read other than going the opposite path of Marluxion, who explained in detail why he didnāt think Prophās progression came from a wolf
He does re-evaluate his own wall post again, which is good? but his original conclusion still doesnāt match with his quotes
responds to a post about voting Emilia from Will, he responds to the answer, but seems more of a ārespond to respondā kinda response
his wolf meta seems to be having a hard time producing his own content, which is mostly what I see here, since the content we get isnāt even very good
his vulgard vote is consistent with his above post, but it still doesnāt have much of an explanation of why those reads are where they are
his second wall post is on Emilia, but this time he votes correctly with his thoughts, which is definitely better than his first case on Chloe
but ya their whole iso is pretty bare bones, and I see no reason to like them, unless someone has polarizing meta on them
Conclusion: Can easily be a wolf here
if you believe will is > rand V, and you think eli is wolfing, why are you not voting eli? why have you not tried to look at the arguments people are presenting for eli v and tried to dispute that in any way?
Is there a reason why youāve beenā¦ kind of putting SPF on hold and trying this way of handling her instead of doing what Iāve been trying to do and trying to exhaustively engage/interact with her? even if she does have a good wolfgame, no one can really escape the fundamental difference of not knowing whose everyoneās alignments are and who does. i need to check your progression on her
okay, I checked your other posts you made at the time and this makes sense. was just confused about your strong vulg scumread you expressed in 1274 and how that reconciled with your vote on will, but I think you did a good job explaining it in your last couple of posts on day 1
what are your thoughts about emilia participating in the will alt discussion with you and ghana? is that something in her wolf range?
does it move the needle on you wrt leafia at all for you?, though? it doesnāt really for me (ie, i still have her as a townread)
iām saying that their general plan as wolf would be to involve pocketing each other - i know that they are both expressing paranoia of each other right now
not trying to set up a dichotomy; i just feel that with knowing that iām town and seeing the vulg wagon it makes me feel like wolves are comfortable with thread consensus atm. this is also why i believe katze was killed last night, so they couldnāt offer a fresh perspective on the game. wolves who would feel comfortable with how d1 was going yesterday are like alice or spf, which is why Iāve dedicated a large portion of my time today to solving spf (would look at alice if i had more time)
well, i think iām the only person on wisp rn lol
why do you think alice is town? again, your stated reasoning in that post did not include any mention of why you think she is a villager, I think
i want a more definitive stance from you here
+1
though i think marl making a dumb read like this is a little villagery for him
Wisp hasnāt done anything incredibly obvious. The worst that Wisp has done is appear premeditated. Wwa was more wolfy in that slot
where do you think wisp has appeared premeditated?
i think that heās been following the game before he replaced in, but iām not using that to read into his alignment
@wisp - if you think eli is a wolf, then why is your vote still on nobody and why are you not making a concerted effort to push him 2.5 hours to eod?
what do you think of the will wagon? the emilia wagon?
the fact that like you have nothing to say really about the most hot button topic person in the game is not inspiring confidence in me
No one cares about my read or agrees with me so seems kinda useless.
+Most ppl who are experienced and engaged with thread more reached opposite conclusion so I am prolly just wrong tbh.
This gives me a different perspective on Emiliaās posts. Not sure if I believe it but itās something new
I have an open question. If (when) I flip V, whatās the next obvious push? Is it wisp?
where have I shown premeditation?
Just the feeling Iām getting bruh
vibe from what lol, how do u vibe that I have pre-planned stuff
if you are refering to my post replacement notes, its basically irrelevant
I just kinda posted them because I had them