in case you haven’t noticed it says LyLo in the day start post
in case you haven’t heard
I am lylo god
I will try my best to pick through however much I can in my limited spare time
then you can get reads
you guys can either bibble babble that whole time or like, use your own time productively and also do that
[quote=“WindwardAway, post:714, topic:89035, full:true”]
Arctic Proph not w/w
immediate reactions are that propg and arctic get town points and arctic anda proph are not w/w
i will do wisp after i get back from soccer
sorry for clogging the thread up with VCs, but i forgot how to spoil stuff on this website
will look over all of these in a couple of hours or so
if proph is mafia wisp wolfreading a partner the moment you replace in for “ignoring this slot” seems like a pretty weird approach to take because there’s nothing for wisp to gain here? he points out that his own posts were bad and so it doesn’t even help to make him look better after proph flips wolf. if he wasn’t trying to look better after proph flipped wolf, it kind of suggests that proph… isn’t flipping wolf, otherwise he’d be trying to gain something here
wisp arguing that gghana is scumreading proph for the wrong reasons while themselves scumreading proph for their own reasons kind of looks unpartnered with gghana
also, if proph is mafia then wisp’s goal here was clearly to try and distance, so why would he get annoyed at someone scumreading proph for different reasons? arguing against gghana’s scumread here only works against his own goal of distancing by coming across as a sort of soft-defending them. i feel that makes it more likely wisp is playing with 2 villagers here, because if proph is mafia the motivation here doesn’t really make sense
surface level take is that this is TMI on gghana being town
i already think leafia looks pretty unpartnered with this slot for the way that she defended them in a way that looks like it comes from an uninformed perspective, which is important especially for leafia who struggles with handling TMI, but this post adds to that
this… is probably looks bad for proph
after some kind of prompt from marl wisp unvotes and then backtracks on some of his scumread of proph but then still shades them later in the post
he sounds incredibly reluctant but still unvotes which looks like he could be trying to weasel out of pushing their partner while still accomplishing distancing via shading. if proph was town, i think unvoting yet still shading makes less sense here than just sticking with it or dropping the read completely
this appeal to emilia looks slightly unpartnered
this is the sequence where i got the impression that wisp was TMI’ing proph v
he was pushing proph yet arguing against marl’s scumread of them
this makes absolutely no sense with proph as wisp’s partner because it makes his distancing attempts redundant and yet wisp was still pushing proph themselves. this makes infinitely more sense if wisp had TMI that proph was a villager and was arguing against marl for the sake of devil’s advocate but still trying to get them killed
like, the standard approach as w/w here is to shade proph without voting and making him go closer to dying. wisp did the exact opposite of that
the way he’s talked about proph here also reminds me of how he talked about will, where he was indeed tmi’ing will as a villager
the main alive person that wisp talked about is proph
which i’m not complaining about because i really need to solve this slot
but i feel like i’m even more confused now because while proph probably has the least villagery posts i think spew looks the best for him
the only thing that looks unpartnered with emilia is the appeal to vote which i’m not going to put too much stock in
like, did you even read my post
if youre a villager why do you not feel a concern to actually solve the game and instead ur pushing the same narrative
