He’s a PR what more is there to discuss
I’m guessing this post is where proph is getting the “I’ve been pushing Vulgard this entire game” thing from
and I know I’m tunneled but I just don’t get the progression, I really don’t
Proph started off with some stuff about vul either being a wolf or a villager doing a play, and then mentioned some weird stuff vul was doing. But I don’t understand how he got from there, to this.
The progression just feels off. Some of the stuff he mentioned about how vul could be a villager just isn’t mentioned? And I don’t like that
I certainly understand why you’re wolf reading Marl, even if I don’t agree with it. Once I get caught up, I think I’ll iso Vulgard to see if that sheds some light on why people are wolf reading him so hard.
Yeah I know
I’m trying to shake it
I really don’t want to repeat what I did in DitF so I’m not going to immediately accept his posts as villagery like I did there
Yeah
She prefers to be a villager by like… a lot
She usually drops in postcount, content, and motivation as the game progresses
Especially as her scumbuds begin to die out and she’s more alone
You really think me talking about the postcap is alignment indicative?
Can you go any deeper than this
How do you feel about my posts after that section of the game?
Okay so I’m going to be fully real with you
Do you ever
Like
Feel somewhat confident in something, so you post it in the thread so you can see if that confidence holds up when you put it out for the world to see? Then as soon as you post it you begin to not feel that way anymore but you don’t want to walk back on it because that’s cowardly?
Cuz that’s what I did with my GGhana wallpost lol
His response after I posted that wall about my read on him wasn’t what I expected and made me feel like I was Very Wrong
There wasn’t any hint of genuine paranoia which felt artificial and pocketey and it kinda destroyed the confidence I had there
I don’t think I want to go there today though for reasons tm, and I still stand by some of my reasons in that wall
Just some icky vibes post-wall
Kinda trying to just
Stay optimistic
Don’t want to get ahead of myself or cocky but I think with the way the thread is going in terms of postcount and readability it’ll be much easier to get a grasp on the game than usual
Hopefully
But I’m starting to get into my usual d1 paranoia and concern mode which isn’t fun
I admit (and I’m pretty sure I said this earlier) that I might have been reading into it as something that wasn’t there but I still stand by the fact that the level of confidence you were showing to the point where you were making aassociation and dissociation reads felt incredibly off coming from you at that point
I kinda thought you would come back and say that you were overplaying things like this
But that still begs the question of why you would do that if, in a lot of your recent games, you’ve been heavily scumread right off the bad for doing far less than this
It almost feels self-destructive (i cant think of a better non-triggering word) and I wouldn’t expect this approach from you but shrug
I don’t see any reason for you to not do this as a wolf and I feel like your posts recently have been pretty lackluster
If you did it for reactions and to get the ball rolling the least you can do is analyze said reactions
Yeah I’m gunna need you to go into more detail than “depth of thought” or I’m not inclined to believe you
Which posts? Where? Why?
Did he post like this in orangevitational btw?
This feels really similar to DitF but i didn’t follow his towngames other than Ciconia very closely
Is this because of your preflip on me? lol
Edit: Cool arctic brough it up a little down the line
Having a hard time seeing where Marl is coming from
I’d check Ciconia to make sure you’re telling the truth but there’s no reason for you to lie about this
If that’s the case then I rescind my townread for his wackness and I’m left with nothing that looks good for him
idk who is pocketing me anymore 
You’re scumreading me by assuming another player is scum, and therefore scumreading someone else by thinking they’re scum with me
Dude what lol
I don’t know if this wraps around to being villagery with how nonsensical it is but I can’t understand your thought process at all which concerns me
But this feels sorta waterfally in that it all ties together and you kinda stream-of-consciousness thoughtvomited as things came to you
dunno dude ur acting weird af
Congrats \o/
Can you expand on this? I actually think Eli has been pretty villagery considering
A. The playerlist
B. His meta
Also I’m preeetttty sure he’s done a similar gimmick in the past? I’d have to doublecheck but it sounds right
omg ily
this is spicy
get out of my head
ily too
time to spliiiiiit
1 Like
If you’re a villager, how would you know what to expect from him when you don’t even know his alignment? This I feel could only come from someone who knows the alignment of the person that they’re talking about.
guess what
have you heard of something called thread reads
I in fact, had an image in my mind of how a wolf would react to thread, and proph basically fit the bill 100%
Chloe I’ve lost multiple games because I had zero confidence in my own skills and because I was too paranoid
At this point I’ll take stuff at face value, especially on day 1
Okay so I know I suck at reading you recently but I’m really concerned with your lack of follow-through regarding the somewhat-RT you did earlier
Sure, you plopped some reads into the thread, but there was no deep analysis like I’d expect from someone who was trying to kick the game into gear
I don’t know what to make of it
This sounds rude and I can’t think of a way for it not to but like… you’re better than this? Regardless of alignment you’re better than this
And I don’t understand
Can you please walk me through your thought process on your current thoughts, with a focus on my slot, how people treated your slot, and how people reacted to our overconfident push
(I’d like thoughts on everything but I think this is a good starting place)
It feels weird to feel like I’m talking down to you since I consider you a stronger player than myself but idk what else to do
1 Like
oh my fucking god
i typoed in my attempt to fix a typo
im done with trying to speak the english language
4 Likes
The thing is is that I wasn’t like trying to convince thread of anything with that post
I was more trying to convince myself
Multiple times I’ve been in games where I thought someone was a villager for kinda dumb reasons and I never pushed on it and I need to stop doing it so I felt like if I planted my flag I’d force myself to have to actually follow through
yeah
gunna need you to expand on both parts in detail
kinda hard to see your thought process with one-word replies that are the easiest possible thing to fake