@willtaylor even if you aren’t a wolf, which only you know, looking at someone’s posts and saying ‘man this person is fake’ doesn’t help anyone if you can’t explain why
it’s a sign you aren’t actually putting forth an effort to look at the motivations behind the posts which is mandatory if we’re going to find you as town
in mafia making yourself readable is just as important as finding the wolves
But it’s gotta be taken in the context of a whole bunch of other memey, sauceless posts which reek of contrivance.
there you go
i didn’t really interpret it as being confrontational, i thought the ‘is that bad’ was genuine
but that post did stick out as off to me earlier as well
Okay, sure, your read on Chloe wasn’t as confident as you presented it. Supposing this is true, how did you get from here [scumread on Chloe because of her telling Leafia about the postcap] to where you are right now [Chloe townlean because of depth of thought]? Can you show me which posts of hers make you think this is now coming from villager Chloe specifically as opposed to wolf Chloe?
OK, got it. Guess a follow-up question to that would be why you instantly had spf at the bottom when she had literally only posted these?
Not sure why you would immediately put spf on the bottom of your readslist for essentially posting an amusing introduction to the game; especially when it is IIRC her first game on the site.
I’m asking you this question because you said you were considering a possible Arctic/SPF/Chloe world, and then when asked you said you were hard villareading Arctic. I want to know if you’re the type of player who does this because I don’t really formulate my reads like this unless I’m doing like, worldbuilding solves in xylo or close to it.
Link me some games then please.
I have to say this post does feel villagery, but at the same time I need more
I still don’t get any sense at all that he’s read through the thread or attempted to catch up every time he’s been posting
I’ll probably try to look at willtaylor’s posts in the morning when my eyes are not tired as shit
Though IIRC from the signup thread he did say that this was his first forum mafia game? This is kind of a universal game health rule I live by but I try not to lunch newbies on Day 1.
@Leafia - when you get a chance, can you talk to me about why exactly you’re townreading me? Just curious because you spent a decent portion of Ciconia tunneling me and right now you’re saying that I’m town because I’m solvey and believe what I’m saying (IIRC). What posts of mine give you that impression exactly?
gghana V -lean I like their vibe
WWA W -lean I dont like their vive
Alice lock W - obvious wolf, doesn’t need explaining.
He’s the dude with the most experience with WWA and is pretty much in obvtown territory so I want a second opinion from him.
No, not really.
Ask me this again if we’re still both around on D2. I’ve been playing most of today from behind and have found it easier to focus on one person today and then see how the rest of the thread reacts to it
Why the excessive focus on Vulgard? Main reason I’m uneasy irt your slot is basically that you haven’t really tried to clear villagers nor try to look at the game-state as a whole and spent much of your time interacting with only GGhana and Vulgard.
My schedule during the weekends isn’t great and I’ve been playing most of this game reading/catching up, with not that much time to take a birds-eye view of the game. Hence why I’ve been focusing mostly on Vulg/talking with Ghana so far as opposed to doing holistic reviews of the gamestate
I should be able to sink some more time into this game D2+ but aorn I’m just trying to keep my head above water.
Vulgard
Leafia
Windy (haven’t read yet but will either drop to bottom or be removed when i do)
Will
Emilia
actually way fucking smaller than i thought
