Wolves usually force themselves to have some kind of weak progression but she just did a full 180
Eli feels mildly wolfy as well. Nothing to do with his gimmick, really, just with his content.
1 Like
I might be thinking this because Iām accustomed to Eli becoming obvious town within his first 50 posts, and Iām not seeing that here so far.
she prefers playing town by a mile and finds it very hard to post and stay motivated as a wolf
iām not sure how much i buy this, especially since you didnāt explain why it being chloe specifically that made warning people about postcounts AI. if you were overplaying it, i think you would have made some attempt to actually answer this to make it seem real so peoplesā reactions to it were genuine, thus getting the game off to a meaningful start
he is taking stances but theyāre typically consensus
iām not sure if the fact that no one is trying to read into any of his specific takes actually means anything for his alignment. iām guilty of this myself but a lot of his posts are being shrugged off as āgood but not villageryā. if he were a wolf here i think itād be quite easy for his partners to throw some cheap townreads on him for this content because it is objectively āgoodā, but iām not really seeing that. this doesnāt mean much if wolves are in lowposters, but itās something to consider
1 Like
the way marl was agreeing with vulgard here yet clearly not actually reading the post reads as a pocket attempt to me but this is probably a stupid read
confbias is one hell of a drug
2 Likes
my stance on eli is that his villagery tunneling/conviction and backtracks are there but his independent solving isnāt, if that makes sense
his reads have been pretty lackluster, like his chloe wallpost was a lot of āi agreeā and not saying much for her alignment, but his villagery fire is still kind of there?
itās a weird situation and iām paranoid because itās possible eli randed wolf halfway through his metamorphosis into becoming a stronger wolf, so only half of his game has improved
LMAO
youāre not wrong i only read the first sentence and typed that
tbf it was as i was walking up the stairs and getting into my apartment though so i was only half paying attention
what did you think was wrong with the gimmick anyway
i feel like thatās not really the problem i have with him
no he isnt
actually digest what heās saying
often if you stop and think about it, he often gives either no opinion or an opinion thats so mixed its nearly useless
that isnt āgiving consensus readsā thats just giving vapid reads, which is wolfy
usually when someone does a gimmick like this itās like
fun?
but seems equally annoying to do as it is to read
which is why it feels forced
i see what you mean but i think itās because he isnāt familiar with a lot of people here so when he asks for meta on them or stuff like ādoes x normally do this as town?ā it reads more like hedge/indecisiveness but in actual fact it may just be him trying to grasp a more comprehensive picture
one thing i will say though is that he doesnāt really do much with the answers to these questions, mainly just acknowledging them. maybe heās keeping more of a mental note, but i think as a villager he would have made the effect of these answers more poignant in his reads, but it doesnāt really look like theyāve had much influence on them. so itās possible these questions were just made for the purposes of posturing and looking interactive to make up for his lackluster opener.
okay but every gimmick is forced because you have to be doing it deliberately
are you saying heās doing it so he can hide being wolfy or what?
this has literally nothing to do with meta
in the exampleās iāve given most of his reads arent much to do with meta
thank you arctic for catching up
when i read them myself i thought the main source of hedge was coming from the way he asked āā¦but iām not sure if X does this as a villagerā and stuff to that effect
yeah this goes beyond hedging
it feels more likely a deliberate attempt to stay neutral on everything
particularly when he doesnāt really do much with the answers to stuff like that too
meh
i kinda want to real time with the guy to see whatās up with that