eli moment
Itās obvious something
(itās not)
i saved this post for later because i wanted to wait for reasons explained further in the post
it basically boils down to chloe being town with some reservations. the way sheās expressed uncertainty on a lot of things reminds me of her normal village play and in a lot of the examples this game it would make more sense as a wolf to take a more headstrong approach to keep mislynch options open such as in gghana and vulgard. thatās the second point, i donāt really feel like thereās any agenda from her and i know she might find it hard to push stuff as a wolf in this list but sheās not at all an incompetent wolf from what iāve heard. it looks like sheās been trying to solve the game from a place of good faith from how willing she is to evolve her reads. itās not like how a wolf changes reads either, because normally wolves do it to fit with the consensus but chloe has usually been changing her reads against the consensus such as with gghana which points to her pushing what she believes in rather than what she thinks would appease the thread
i have two reservations though
the first being that chloe normally tries to interact with me much more than she has been this game. iām not sure if itās due to post cap and itās probably also my fault but iām kind of missing the way we bounce ideas off of each other. if sheās a wolf sheād probably find these interactions harder to replicate naturally and so avoiding them makes sense
the second one is what caused me to save my read on chloe for later. i got the impression that chloe and proph were overplaying the paranoia thing they have with each other to the point where it looked pretty forced and like a deliberate attempt to look unaligned, so i wanted to see if this continued because this made me feel like they had partner equity. it didnāt really continue though, so i feel better about this really
basically i think sheās probably a villager but sheās been a bit different to last game in terms of direct interactions with me specifically, but this may just be due to lolpostcap
1 Like
lol
this is actually a fair point and good on you for bringing it up
i donāt know if i can quite explain why i havenāt been interacting with you other than the fact that it feels like weāre in uhā¦ different worlds? Itās like weāre not on the same wavelength this game in terms of our approach, I guess
I donāt really know how to explain it
I wanted to reach out to you earlier and bounce some ideas but you were in the groove and i didnāt want to ruin that for you
i also usually originally interact with you to try to figure out your alignment but i found you as town pretty much right off the bat so i went to focus on interacting w/ other people
2 Likes
i see
well
itās just sad actually
hopefully we can play more tomorrow but thereās a decent chance i eat the n1
i wont lie i also kinda lost some of my hope for working together with people when alice told the entire thread to ignore me and she followed through on it despite my attempts to talk to her
i thought i upset her and i didnt know what i did wrong so i kinda uh
sulked for a while
I have a bit of time before I gotta go for dinner, then I should be around at EoD but likely from mobile
anyone wanna bounce thoughts?
Okay if Vulgard is town then who are the wolves? You will never convince me the entire team is in Eli/Will/Emilia. That list has 0 to 1 wolves in it, tops. Leafia I still donāt really townread and the only one who did is Alice. Leafia was also doing a ton of hyping up Alice (I called it simping at the time), so maybe the two could be partnered? Iāve also āclearedā SPF fairly easily today just because they havenāt really felt like theyāre pushing Agenda. If people think But Vulgard is town I still think Prophy is town, so where does that leave us?
One post remains but Iām going to bed soon anyway so ask me questions or give me thoughts and Iāll do one more big boi post before I sleep and decide on who I want to vote today.
We really should not vote Prophy. We really should not vote Eli again.
Will I am not unwilling but Iām not fully sold, this might still be the best bet if Vulgard is town though.
btw Iām vetoing my own wagon
there are only 3 votes on me currently and SPF hasnāt even given the reason why sheās on my wagon yet
1 Like
fellas Iām having a bit of a crisis
like
looking at game state I honestly donāt really see proph flipping my v because I donāt really have any theories that make sense unless literally every single LHF slot is a wolf which I doubt
but if Iām wrong I feel like Iād just retreat into the sewers and never return mentally
So I want to like go really hard and convince thread to kill proph but if Iām wrong Iād feel like shit
someone help
I saw that you were dead certain Proph is town, but I didnāt really like how he didnāt even address the fact that I put him as scummier than Vulgard for a while despite being in the thread at the same time as me. I get that he was probably focused on GGhana since both of them were just going back and forth, but the lack of interaction with me while I was in the thread last night was kinda weh. I wasnāt in the best of moods but I still wanted to talk with people if they were willing to, it just seemed like nobody really was except for Arctic so I gave up.
Okay if Proph is town then who are the wolves? You will never convince me the entire team is in Eli/Will/Emilia. That list has 0 to 1 wolves in it, tops. Leafia I still donāt really townread and the only one who did is Alice. Leafia was also doing a ton of hyping up Alice (I called it simping at the time), so maybe the two could be partnered? Iāve also āclearedā SPF fairly easily today just because they havenāt really felt like theyāre pushing Agenda. (ok memes aside SPF is obvious village and I will die on this hill) If people think Proph is town I still think Vulgard is kinda town, so where does that leave us?
One post remains but Iām going to bed soon anyway so ask me questions or give me thoughts and Iāll do one more big boi post before I sleep and decide on who I want to vote today.
We really should not vote Vulgard (actually maybe we should I donāt fucking know). We really should not vote Eli again.
Will I am not unwilling but Iām not fully sold, this might still be the best bet if Proph is town though.
(the fact that almost all of this is most of my own thoughts with the names switched around is pretty good ngl)
I think Vulās read on Alice has quite a bit of merit and I wanna look that way and I especially want to hear spfās thoughts on what Vul said earlier, too
I think thereās still the possibility that Proph is a wolf but Iād rather do my due diligence tonight and figure that out
I donāt really think the two are W/W fwiw
But I canāt quite remember why
Iāve yet to read windās posts after the thing i quoted from vul but if youāre saying she got better, and if arctic is saying she got better (i think arctic said that? arctic has she gotten better) then iām okay with cutting her some slack and brushing off her early weirdness as not being up to speed
Iām kinda in sleepy sheepy mode
Weh
Also thread feels villagery right now
1 Like
I want Proph to die so that I finally get gratification and also I can recognize if Iām a fucking terrible player or not
this is not a very good reason to kill Proph but I think he should die today regardless