That your PoE wasn’t that huge of a tell as to what to do. She was already scumleaned, and hippo was townie anyway
If you mean PoE you just gotta do it right.
If you do it right and can say with 100% confident their the scum team then it’s the scum team.
I’ve solved entire scum teams multiple times before.
Also hi I’m back not for long but my eyes have calmed down on the pain but my head hasn’t
You hear that bob might stab steve. You never met Steve or Bob. Someone else says Steve will stab Bob. You have equal info. 50/50 chance. Choosing who to side with would be based on ‘luck’
I’m just saying, sometimes the info accumulated will not point in any direction, or will point in several directions
EVO, can I tell you what I think you could have improved on (from my PoV), now that I’m chill and all?
we somehow saved wazza d1 when i was absolutely willing to keep my vote on him
also go the heck to sleep wazza
1 Like
that’s generally when you need to try to look deeper
some times you do get those split decisions
Check this out.
https://forum.mafia451.com/t/mha-mafia-game-thread-game-over/3835
I solved the entire scum team.
I caught both Orangeandblack and Banana as well as GKB.
Yeah, I was just saying, sometimes you should accept that the info you had conflicted and it might be down to picking the least risky option
Remember to be open-minded! You scumread me because it looked like to you I was pocketing sulit, which is fine. Your D1 is fine.
Except what happened is that by D1 you convinced yourself I was scum and looked for little things in my posts that you could use to convince yourself even more that I was scum (confirmation bias). This began to narrow your vision and then most of your reads revolved around me being scum because of it. I have done this too before so don’t worry (confirmation bias is kinda dangerous). Check out NFoL4 sometime, and check Napoleon/Emilia interactions, I got Emilia mislynched because I placed them in PoE and looked for everything I could to convince myself that they were scum. (even though the game was nearly unloseable I did end up convincing myself that Emilia was a wolf).
I think looking for small-ish things is fine (such as: “does this interaction feel real?”, “does this reaction feel geniune”, “what about tone?”) but remember to look at the bigger picture. For instance, you suspected that scum was driving the conversation. Try and look at what agenda I’m trying to push for. Try and evaluate me from both a town perspective and a scum perspective and I think you would do better.
Anyways overall, you did better after you mislynched me because you seemed to have learned from the mislynch. Except you then lost confidence and then began to question your other scumreads, who were actually scum 