the read was based on TMI and incredibly forced because it’s phrased as though sam is being massively miscleared and towncored, despite it being day 1 and the extent of reads on them being ‘slightly villagery’
if PKR was a villager he would have taken the approach of “sam is a newbie and is getting villa read for reasons which are NAI” instead of going guns blazing on some crusade against a player who literally only has 10 posts
wolves like to call each other wolves and shade each other without actually pushing each other because it gives the other credit in the event that one flips, yet they don’t actually have to push the other closer to dying
stealth’s ISO doesn’t make me massively feel either way except for this one post
which is an incredibly weird post to make if stealth had TMI that gghana and leafia were both flipping town
it really looks like a villager thinking he’s had a eureka moment
also, assuming emilia is a villager here (which i think is the most likely scenario), this is a dumb post to make as a wolf who could easily just accept my meta scumread on emilia without having to look bad in the process
it’s not exactly a fair assessment to say that wind would have started scumreading cloned and PKR
the point is that at EoD they were being townread
wind said she would likely re-eval their slots overnight, which if they are wolves the wolves would not want to happen since they’d want to keep pkr and cloned being read as villagers
If cloned and pkr are villagers and were being read correctly as villagers, wolves killing wind does not make sense since she said she’s going to re-eval them which means there’s a chance she came into the day incorrectly scumreading them, which wolves would like
the main things of significance from sulit’s ISO are her scumreads of stealth and cloned
and you can’t really say she died because of her stealth scumread, because literally the entire game shared this so it doesn’t explain why she was killed over gghana
there are more reads than i thought there were, her posting is very fluid and she seems comfortable in the game
they also have no signs of pushing agenda at all (although i’m not sure how valid this is, because something tells me emilia doesn’t push agenda as a wolf)
i particularly like these reads
wind also made a good point about emilia’s defence of herself not using LAMIST or any bad arguments, she normally raises actual good points and dives into why her perspective does not come from a wolf
also @GGhana
if whysper does end up being lw then pkr’s push becomes even more viable as w/w
i just remember emilia saying this: