I also remember seeing the earlier posts where people were saying Emilia sounded scummy. But I’ve also heard that Emilia often sounds that way at first, so people who don’t know her well thinks she’s scummy.
that’s worth looking into, I might ISO him next.
I feel like i’m not very good at reading him, but after a couple days there are usually enough posts that i have a somewhat better idea of his alignment. I think i’m more successful at reading him off associations than purely off his ISO, so I’ll be looking for how he posts around other slots.
she got pushed as scummy the entirety of FAM as I recall but her post count was way out of her scumrange according to several people, and she also made a couple posts that seemed more likely uninformed than not. not sure how good she is at faking it but I just think she’s a very easy LHF cause she gets defaulted into the PoE regardless of alignment. I don’t think she’s done anything in this game that I think would never come from a villager, and in fact I think she’s done a couple things that probably never come from a wolf (as mentioned above).
1 Like
also none of her self-defense reads as LAMIST; it all looks legitimately like she’s prompting people to really examine her motivations and think about why she’d do certain things as either alignment.
Haha, I think I’ve seen people comment that when she posts in a way that aggravates them, then they know she’s town. 
1 Like
btw I think GGhana’s readlist yesterDay sucked (not sure what his current reads are but maybe he’ll answer that when he comes back)
last i saw was his readlist saying there was definitely a wolf in arc/marsh and that sam/stealth’s slots should be killed, and i think all of those are terrible
they aren’t outside of his townrange but he’s not at a townclear yet imo
still wouldn’t yeet him today but if he lives for a while it’s very likely he’s actually a villager with completely incorrect reads
he also stuck emilia into his poe there
marsh flipped town and iirc he’s been pushing arctic? but he’s just going from one v flip to the next by pushing people making the villagers flip, when i think there’s a high chance this game is villagers pushing each other and the wolves are doing whatever, kind of being present in the thread but not really strongly pushing? that’s the feeling i get, at least, although i haven’t been here long enough in realtime to verify it.
oh maybe
i haven’t read his most recent posts so that’s possible, i guess i could just ISO him backwards to look for his reads
yeah i did see that
the softing isn’t necessarily towny but going ahead with the claim anyway despite 3 other claims kind of is
i remember being pretty sure she was a wolf at sod2 because she had given hardly any reads and she was missing her sassy one-liners
she’s still probably town because the stuff she’s doing isn’t exactly wolfy it just doesn’t fit in with what i know
I saw a couple sassy one-liners in her ISO actually
maybe she didn’t start doing those till later in D2 though, I remember mostly seeing them in interactions with my slot (Aelin) and GGhana iirc
i don’t think i’ve actually ISO’ed her so you might be right
she did improve day 2 i think
1 Like
her D1 didn’t look particularly impressive, i’ll say that, but her own defense of why she claimed jailkeeper looked pretty reasonable and her D2 looked good
also her postcount in D2 is much higher i think
what’s the status on Eli btw? I feel like he’s kinda just there but I only saw a couple posts from him and they don’t give me particularly towny vibes. I’d have to ISO him to get a read on him, though.