Watch Your Mouth!: Sophomore Year (3/17) - Day 5 - Planters (Mafia) Win!

Is your list in order from town to wolf? If so, I was curious why Troch is 4th from the bottom.

I was told to meta you by Marshal :man_facepalming:

Iā€™m not criticizing you for doing the meta read. Iā€™m criticizing Alice for previously criticizing others for doing these meta reads and yet doing them herself and also saying nothing about you doing so.

Itā€™s not ordered within Tier.

Also @Chloe @DatBird VC?

1 Like

Okay, got it.

Though I guess Iā€™ll follow up. Where would you place Troch now? Is she town or town lean, or are you putting her in null?

Theyā€™re null for me.

How about Luxy now after all these interactions? Still null?

I think Marshalā€™s point on them was decent but my gut says theyā€™re V rn.

1 Like

Except that Iā€™m only using meta as a way to supplement my argument and to counter Appelā€™s defense of you, not basing my entire read on you as what other people here do.

My main argument is that youā€™ve spent much of the game trying to negate TRs while Appel claims that you spent more time solving slots which is a stretch being that when compared to your usual town play that you havenā€™t solved much at all.

Luxy actually has a better case on you rather than ā€œWhysper is in her wolf metaā€ or ā€œWhysper did X in WW and she is doing X here, so sheā€™s a wolf.ā€

Frankly Iā€™m going to give time to Whysper, though.

At least theyā€™re trying to make an effort here while Moleā€™s just completely lethargic.

That would be because Iā€™m probably not gonna see day 2

ā€¦if youā€™re V then living to see D2 doesnā€™t matter. Find wolves. Case Jane.

Iā€™m sure one of Wazza/Jane is a wolf.

And Whysper showing up to vote on me is probably a wolf too. I already did case them

Hereā€™s the thing: at that point in time, Whysper had made 3 posts ā€œnegating townreadsā€ that are not necessarily wolfy given the context behind them, and one where she ended up townleaning said person later (Derps). She had made 3 posts talking about her townreads.

Despite me independently reading Whysper as town, I wasnā€™t defending them. I was pointing out that your basis for scumreading them is flawed. It was objectively incorrect, and thatā€™s why I had a problem with it. Iā€™d advice you actually read through our discussion again, because I donā€™t like repeating myself.

Why is specifically Whisper a wolf for voting you?

V :butter: O :butter: T :butter: Eimage C :butter: O :butter: U :butter: N :butter: T

Accused Voted by Votes
SirDerpsAlot Esquiddy 1/9
Trochilidae Trochilidae 1/9
Surge Surge 1/9
EliThePsycho Insanity 1/9
Whysper Luxy, Moleland 2/9
Moleland Alice, Jane, SirDerpsAlot, Whysper, Marshal, an_gorta_pratai 6/9
Luxy Wazza 1/9
Not voting EliThePsycho, Appelsiini, PokemonKidRyan 3
BUTTER ROLL 1/9

IF I MISSED A VOTE
PING ME
OR
CHLOE OR SOMETHING IDK

1 Like

Why is this?

I donā€™t think Iā€™ve seen a single time where Mole was town, and I let them get off the hook for stupid things such as ā€œA wolf probably wouldnā€™t do thisā€ so Iā€™ll read him with a different mindset this time.

@sulit