Watch Your Mouth!: Sophomore Year (3/17) - Day 5 - Planters (Mafia) Win!

Is your list in order from town to wolf? If so, I was curious why Troch is 4th from the bottom.

I was told to meta you by Marshal :man_facepalming:

I’m not criticizing you for doing the meta read. I’m criticizing Alice for previously criticizing others for doing these meta reads and yet doing them herself and also saying nothing about you doing so.

It’s not ordered within Tier.

Also @Chloe @DatBird VC?

1 Like

Okay, got it.

Though I guess I’ll follow up. Where would you place Troch now? Is she town or town lean, or are you putting her in null?

They’re null for me.

How about Luxy now after all these interactions? Still null?

I think Marshal’s point on them was decent but my gut says they’re V rn.

1 Like

Except that I’m only using meta as a way to supplement my argument and to counter Appel’s defense of you, not basing my entire read on you as what other people here do.

My main argument is that you’ve spent much of the game trying to negate TRs while Appel claims that you spent more time solving slots which is a stretch being that when compared to your usual town play that you haven’t solved much at all.

Luxy actually has a better case on you rather than ā€œWhysper is in her wolf metaā€ or ā€œWhysper did X in WW and she is doing X here, so she’s a wolf.ā€

Frankly I’m going to give time to Whysper, though.

At least they’re trying to make an effort here while Mole’s just completely lethargic.

That would be because I’m probably not gonna see day 2

…if you’re V then living to see D2 doesn’t matter. Find wolves. Case Jane.

I’m sure one of Wazza/Jane is a wolf.

And Whysper showing up to vote on me is probably a wolf too. I already did case them

Here’s the thing: at that point in time, Whysper had made 3 posts ā€œnegating townreadsā€ that are not necessarily wolfy given the context behind them, and one where she ended up townleaning said person later (Derps). She had made 3 posts talking about her townreads.

Despite me independently reading Whysper as town, I wasn’t defending them. I was pointing out that your basis for scumreading them is flawed. It was objectively incorrect, and that’s why I had a problem with it. I’d advice you actually read through our discussion again, because I don’t like repeating myself.

Why is specifically Whisper a wolf for voting you?

V :butter: O :butter: T :butter: Eimage C :butter: O :butter: U :butter: N :butter: T

Accused Voted by Votes
SirDerpsAlot Esquiddy 1/9
Trochilidae Trochilidae 1/9
Surge Surge 1/9
EliThePsycho Insanity 1/9
Whysper Luxy, Moleland 2/9
Moleland Alice, Jane, SirDerpsAlot, Whysper, Marshal, an_gorta_pratai 6/9
Luxy Wazza 1/9
Not voting EliThePsycho, Appelsiini, PokemonKidRyan 3
BUTTER ROLL 1/9

IF I MISSED A VOTE
PING ME
OR
CHLOE OR SOMETHING IDK

1 Like

Why is this?

I don’t think I’ve seen a single time where Mole was town, and I let them get off the hook for stupid things such as ā€œA wolf probably wouldn’t do thisā€ so I’ll read him with a different mindset this time.

@sulit