Oh gee I have too much to say. This is just the first 50 posts or so
Tonally I townread both of them, but I agree that reading Whysper at this stage is bad.
What was it that Cent said again?
Oh yeah
(I also think Centuries is V just because this is exactly my thoughts, and he seems to be solving independently as well. His opening reminded me of FoL 29 where he was town.)
If it’s taking too long, I suggest you just leave it be and talk in thread while making reads at the same time. You’ll never catch up at this rate.
I don’t know much about Pokemon but it’s not like Latias looks extraordinarily feminine or anything. Have headpats, Mist.
I still think Intensify is >V, both tonally and because I see their behavior coming more from a town perspective in general. I do want to go take a look at their scumgame, however, so I’ll focus more on this slot when I’ve done so.
I didn’t mention this earlier but despite them having a big focus on finding scum rather than finding town, they’re very likely V here.
Chili it is
To be fair, the thought crossed my mind but I was gonna call you Dae as I figured you’d have the same reaction as Thunal
Bleh
Is this purely because of his fluffposting? If so, I disagree with this.
Is it angleshooting if I say I think he’s >V just because he was reading FoL 29
The rest (up to 1k)
Yeah, pretty sure Chili is town.
Bleh. I can’t see why a wolf wouldn’t do that, as Light is easy to push and put suspicion on. Fluffposting/not caring shouldn’t clear people unless in specific circumstances; it’s fine to take it into consideration when solving a slot, but that alone shouldn’t dictate the read. That’s what I did to Hippo in DGADT, and he was a wolf.
Same for being reasonable. I can tell town to stop detonating other town and be a wolf
Her reads look just fine to me, she has good reasonings behind them as well. If a player is competent enough to fake that, there’s no need to think they couldn’t genuinely make those kinds of reads as well.
The problem is that you seem to think about “would a townie do this?” instead of “would SETH do this as town?” Seth has somewhat of an extraordinary playstyle, so the latter should be applied to him more.
A petition to delete that post altogether
Oh?
…Oh.
We’re not hammering him. There’s still a lot of time left.
Even though I said being reasonable shouldn’t clear someone either
Ash gets town points for this post
Do I townread this?
…I totally do.
It gives you a chance to express your thoughts and opinions. Scum can do this too, but that’s where we judge whether or not the catch up post looks performative.
