Classic delay tactic
This could go either way idk
Justified response to naked vote
Sulit explains and hounds them for an answer–no reply
Whysper:
I would say I currently TR Vulgard and Wazza the most. Their posts so far seem reasonable and helpful. And they have the general feel of the previous game I played with them where they were town.
There are a lot of vitriolic comments going around early, which always come off as wolfish to me by default, but I suppose some people just consider that their strategy. I want to take a closer look at Luxy and Geyde to see if they’ve actually started making useful comments.
No real progression here but they did say earlier they just got back from reading up some
This could be opportunistic or a normal newish town reaction
Whysper:
No, not just you, Leafia. I’ve been disliking Cecil’s read posts too despite her getting TR’d by a few others. I planned to take a closer look later, but thought I’d at least express my agreement with you in the meantime.
No visible progression here either
I confirm her read with some mech talk -> TR?
Whysper:
I’m not exactly sure what you’re getting at with this question. I would expect a wolf to go ahead and continue posting, or stop if he just got bored with it. So it’s either way. But for town, I’d expect him to stop.
Arguments on light seem consistent
Whysper:
You know, I considered whether I should adjust my style after my first game so that I could fit in better. But then I decided that wouldn’t work out in the long run. Ironically I’d have to perform in order to match some expected style that doesn’t seem performative. That would be too stressful and tiring.
So I’ll continue my best to learn methods of solving and helping out town. My style will just have to grow organically but will likely never match the somehow ideal style a few people seem to expect others must play like.
This feels like a towny thought
Not sure how to read this
Whysper:
Hi Ash. Yeah, getting through the posts again. I was about to ask about the current PoE since it looks like it got reduced quite a bit. Great shot by Centuries but otherwise the rest are sad to see.
I know I’m kind of a null at this point. I just ask now for guidance on who the current best shot is. I think I saw Intensify was still on lists. App has kind of moved in and out of PoE.
Whysper:
Oh okay
Whysper:
Okay, here’s some stuff I found on PKR while looking again.
So his shot against Mist was OMGUS?
PokemonKidRyan:
Yes, exactly.
I think Mist is just… not making much sense to me atm tbh.
Like, they had me and Mole as optimal shots.
Mist had Mole as optimal shot, and he did turn out scum.
So there’s an argument that PKR was one of those bussing Seth?
Hmmm, another scum giving up?
Yeah, this looks bad. He wasn’t following the PoE and went on his own with the shot.
Still, I think I might hold out my shot for Vulgard’s opinion. Hoping he gets on again soon.
Everything so far looks pretty good,
Whysper:
Out of these, I do think PKR is looking the scummiest. I think Gorta is town. He just seems too much like my previous game with him where he ended up being town, though I originally confused him as scum.
up until here. Here it starts to break a little
Whysper:
Hmm yeah. Just with all these towns getting shot at, it almost seems like a whole re-evaluation is needed. But from what I saw of the posts from PKR regarding Mist, he does seem scummy. The whole shot against Mist just for pushing him was bad. Mist wasn’t even in the PoE from what I recall.
/shoot PKR @Marshal
Whysper:
Oh God no
Trying to figure out if this looks like a scummy reaction to the shot
Whysper:
Well, it sounds like Intensify needs to sleep. And some time to cool down will be good for everyone. The change in peoples’ behavior is startling. Appel does feel like a completely different person than earlier on.
I still think Wazza seems town just letting out his frustrations. I think he did take the results of SFoL63 hard on himself. I don’t think he would be mentioning all that if he was wolf this time around.
Whysper:
I found the whole thing between Wazza and Appel strange. Wazza seemed to accuse Appel out of nowhere and I wasn’t sure that I agreed with his logic. But then Appel did seem to change and get pretty defensive and argumentative with Wazza. I don’t know if that’s just 2 villagers getting heated, or if maybe one of those 2 is wolf.
Whysper:
Hmm, I was thinking that App’s response was seeming like genuine frustration, but when you bring up the lack of shots against him, that does seem weird.
Some solving I guess, but could also be parrotting the consesnus.
I also looked back at whysper’s other game, and in addition to about twice as many posts, Town!Whysper is a lot more willing to point their vote at whoever they’re thinking about, and I’m not seeing that here.
so I think I believe a whysper scum world
