Gorta feels town with these recent posts, he’s pushing a narrative that encourages reevaluating and looking at people we haven’t thought about.
I see what you mean, but at this point we do have deep wolves and we need to analyze things that we wouldn’t normally. This doesn’t include hero shots, but every shot needs to be really damn well explained.
1 Like
idrc, it looks to me like y’all are buddy-buddy.
And anyways, gorta isn’t actually reevaling. He’s just continuing to say that everyone else is wrong to TR people
I’ve led a wagon like that exactly once as scum, and the way I did it was so different from what I did here. My push when I was scum was literally just repeating the townie was scum since I couldn’t think of any good arguments. Here I cased Intensify and genuinely believed he was a wolf for a lot of reasons. I also questioned whether he would actually flip scum at the last minute, like I usually do as town.
When we don’t re-evaluate every fabric of this game we lose. It happened in SFoL 63, SFoL 61.5,Purgatory III, and CFM2. I am not saying we SR everyone that is a consensus townread nor that we blast there right away, but we need to be damn sure that these people are town because like it or not there is a deep wolf here
1 Like
Your point is?
anyways the fact that there are reasons to SR them makes it only a little better
When our PoE shots keep hitting townies then it’s likely that our PoE is wrong and in fact not game winning
2 Likes
Re-evaluating is not,
“All that stuff we though before must be wrong”
Re-evaluating is,
“Do these people still look towny in light of flips and recent interactions?”
I think that you might be under the illusion that to “re-eval”, you have to answer “no”.
I’m not against re-evaluating them
I’m against people scumreading them for no reason other than:
“They were townread, and I’m re-evaluating”
I also think that Sulit, Apprentice, and Gorta are likely all town. Sulit’s thoughts and reads made a lot of sense despite her lack of involvement, Apprentice’s self destructing behavior feels unfortunately like town, and Gorta’s recent posts look good.
I agree with one of these
It happens to be the one with reasonably solid reasoning
1 Like
Re-evaluating in this situation is “Are we still sure that these people are town because the general PoE is shit”
I never said we scum read them just for being townread. If you read my posts carefully I said we need to start fresh and find out if they are town instead of just going with the flow and assuming “yup, this is town”. A fair bit of these guys will still be town, but we are looking for possible deepwolves in those slots.
Luxy was confident that we have a few wolves out of the PoE and that said PoE was shit, so we are going to investigate that today. We will find those that are town out of the generally townread people and see if there are wolves in that crowd
Troch seems nervous in her first posts which might be slightly scum indicative? Then again I was too just since I’m new to this forum and I know Troch is too.