Probably impulsive then? I mean if scum are just playing badly… we’re lucky? But I don’t really want to bet on “oh yeah we got lucky scum team sux”
Not exactly? I don’t think Joat would out a roadblock… unless you just do for some reason. Wouldn’t it be better to just stay qieut and pretend you’re not a Joat and hide amongst the other 3 Joat claims
Sometimes you just gotta gamble.
Do you find that scummy then?
wut
Uhh might be a little hard but could you explain this or format this a little better? Kinda hard to read and follow no offense
| Vote Target | Voted by | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Illwei | ArcticXI, WindwardAway | 2/7 |
| PokemonKidRyan | SirDerpsAlot | 1/7 |
| Shurian | Intensify | 1/7 |
I don’t think they’d make the same mistake on N2, especially because they know that one of the JoaTs used their protection already. They’re pretty much guaranteed a kill tonight.
That’s also what I thought, but I also think Eli’s not very good at the claim game, so I’m more inclined to believe him than not. It would only hurt town if he lied as town, because scum knows who they targeted, meaning they almost definitely also know who used a protective action, and they also know for a fact whether they really RB’d Eli or not.
Yesterday for sure it would’ve been better for a real JoaT to hide, but I think we had two slightly impulsive JoaTs who wanted to out their claims due to pressure/misunderstanding what was going on, and it’s resulted in 2 out of 4 JoaT claims being real.
they gambled halfway and not the whole way.
[quote=“Intensify, post:2201, topic:85229”]
I don’t find it scummy of Arctic. Whether Illwei finds it scummy, I don’t know.
yeah that’s why I added the tl;dr after it. Just read that lol.
or I’ll just rewrite this.
Assume Eevee or Eli is JoaT B.
Assume min or Maple is JoaT A.
Roleblock a JoaT B claim and hope you block their protection.
Kill a JoaT A claim because JoaT B isn’t blocking.
JoaT B isn’t going to try to protect their own counterclaim.
but scum RB’d a JoaT B claim and also attacked a JoaT B claim, from what I understand. That just doesn’t seem logical to me.
I mean I didn’t say he would have to lie? I just said that like he could not mention anything about it to confuse scum. No one’s gonna randomly ask Eli “psst do you know if u got rb’ed Eli?”
Oh I was so mesmerized by that part I didn’t even see the bottom part
Ok yeah that’s much more understandable thanks, but like I said, doesn’t this come off as impulsive or nonchalant scum then?
it does, but I don’t see what they stand to gain by being nonchalant, especially when they need to up their game because we yeeted Marl.
I just really think someone wasn’t paying attention or forgot who had claimed which JoaT, and since both Arctic and Light commented on it, it wouldn’t be them because they would have mentioned it in the scumchat when deciding a kill.
I already townread Arctic long before this, but I had Light toward the bottom of my list and this makes him look significantly better imo. So that’s why I think it’s important.
what’s less worrying is that they presumably targeted Eevee, because I think they probably thought Eevee would solve the game.
what’s more worrying is why they roleblocked Eli instead of min, but I’m guessing it’s because Eli seemed the most likely to be a real JoaT as he claimed 4th, which is not a move that even makes sense unless he really is a JoaT.
Still feels kinda tinfoilish though, but I guess in the end it doesn’t matter since I read both slots as town for the most part
idk, maybe I’m reading too much into it. I have a tendency to do that lol.
with that taken into account, though, my PoE is between Derps/Illwei/PKR for the time being, and in no particular order, with Shurian and you above that. Everyone else is a townread unless something drastic comes up.
Also where the heck is everyone else.
It feels like it’s just been us 4 talking this entire time.
Oh hey would you look at that as soon as I mention us being the only ones here, 2 other people show up
3, I barely did anything. Heck I’m now with my family at Universal Studios Singapore, which means I’ll be off for a bit having fun.
I’m of the idea that something feels off. I don’t know what, but it feels off.
Have fun! ^^
I’ve already come to that conclusion, and it’s not just the lack of activity here.
