Witch(Neutral Offensive)(Could use a new name)

Witch can’t find the classes of the evils though. And it’s still a bad play for them to out evils

I never said that.

That’s why I added night immunity. And stop comparing ToL to ToS.

That doesn’t mean that the player you controlled is a killer. They could just be an unlucky sheriff. And controlling evils twice isn’t a good play. You’re more useful controlling BD

Scorned is also a NE yet has a different win con.

Give it perm death immunity

It’s already damn good, I don’t think it needs it

2 Likes

Honestly I’d make it so that it isn’t immune to BD Killing roles (Knight)

1 Like

But that’s just because I like scum autovests

What about perm death immunity but can die from BD

I mean, that’s like the same thing as one-shot in most cases

If you’re attracting enough attention for the scum to try and kill you twice you probably deserve to die lol

1 Like

Why? Knight can still kill Witch, it just takes 2 hits.

Fair enough I guess, but with a class that’s already darn good I think letting it be killed by Knights is a fair weakness

1 Like

Yeah, but why would a knight attack an immune twice instead of outting them

Still disagree with making a false difficulty.

It’s not a bad witch if they out evils in there death note, They lost if they die.

It’s easily going to find killers.

My point is surviving for a NE isn’t needed unless you want to put fake difficulty onto a class.

The job of a NE is to help evils not be hard to win or survive

3 Likes

Answer: the class helps them more alive

I’ve explained why it’s bad just stop.

This isn’t Tos Logic aka make a class hard just because, when a class perfectly works as a counter role without having to survive.

I’m not saying that having to survive is always better

I am saying that there are legitimate reasons to have a class do so

1 Like

Yeah when there goal is to survive like alchemist

Not when there goal is to help evils.

well this one is to do both and is thus neither of the 2 you listed