Bigtown mash discussion oh god oh fuck

Roleblocker

Jailkeeper

Tracker

Watcher

Doctor

Beholder

Alien

Neighbourizer

Arsonist

Redirector

^ these roles get an odd and even cycle copy each

1-shot vigilante

universal backup

Bus Driver

Coroner

Death Vanillizer (if you die you publicly vanillize a player)

^ these are all ungated roles, there’s only one of each

I want to make a big town mash, these roles all kinds suck. I want some feedback

Alignments are:

6 Sons of Adam - wolf team

1 Neutral Evil - wins if town loses the game (they win if wolves win, they’re the only person alive, or if everyone is dead)

Neutral Evil inherits the factional kill if all Sons of Adam are dead

If the neutral evil alone wins the wolves still lose

Coroner can only detect Sons of Adam, not the Neutral Evil

Everyone else is a villager

no

4 Likes

Does everyone know who is an odd person and who is an even person?

odd night/even night arsonist is reallllly slow

i forgot what alien does

watchers + bus driver + UB all randing town sounds kinda awful for wolves

What’s a big town

We don’t need all four

What in the world

Keep this, remove Arso

Please no, it discourages people from voting out a potential evil

Also this is a minimash smh

It should be called an NYC game

yes

thats the point

fair point

what should i replace them with

smalltown but its a mash

why not

weak hider

3 Likes

image

1 Like

Sounds interesting and fun.

stay away satan

bus driver should definitely be gated (1-shot or sth), watchesr if kept in should be n1/n2 for the sake of not giving the wolves total hell
probably not all my thoughts but those are what i have 4 now

you can try gutless watcher

which is watcher which can’t see factional
it could work alright in this setup tbh

1 Like

watcher kind of sucks on wolves in this kind of setup
so going the mad17 approach and giving them some goodies is reasonable

1 Like