I’d likely just choose Marl or Intensify with that ability.
Fair
But then there’s the headache of when the Butler defies their ability because… that’s not defined lmao
Hmm
Two things
Why does it never come from villager exactly?
I knew that PKR was at very least bluffing or lying
I told Amelia about this.
I also thought my ability could find evils every night.
So what was a good way to present my information and PKR being fake Amne info in such a way that it did not out me as Amne so that I don’t instantly die after outting as Amne with such a powerful ability?
Well claim Librarian.
Call the person I know is lying as Lunatic
Push them to be the execution
Once I have the second night of information
Obviously Librarian is a one time ability and not an ongoing ability so evils don’t bother killing me most of the time.
Night 2 happens and ends
Safely out as Amne having the second batch of names with a evil in it.
Oh cool.
Neat theory except I told Amelia about my Amne claim in whispers, so there was someone who knew I knew PKR wasn’t Amne and knew my Librarian bluff was a plan to keep myself alive long enough to get another batch of info while at the same time executing someone who I knew was lying about their role.
Unless you want to claim me and Amelia are scummates, there was literally someone that would’ve prevented me from doing that IF I was evil, thus this theory falls.
WAIT WAIT.
YOU THINK… me and PKR are scummates who thunderdommed out of nowhere for no reason at all?
what…
Where is the proof or basis for this
1 Like
Basically.
Any theory claiming that there was some sort of convoluted plan to execute or towncore people with my Librarian claim is practically false and impossible because Amelia could easily come in at any time and just go “But Intensify you did this in the whispers you are lying you are big bad”
The whole librarian bluff’s goal was to keep me long enough to live to receive a second batch of names while at the same time executing a person who I knew was lying about their claim.
This is easy to dispute and admittedly, PKR does have a chance to be town but tell me how wanting a scum to become proven town while getting rid of at least one townie can ever come from town. Because that’s literally what would’ve happened if we had followed your plan.
I’m not falling for this obvious lie. You only told Amelia about what you supposedly planned to do to cover your own butt should someone call you out on it.
???
And you think if I told Amelia “hey I’m gonna locktown the guy I just called fake” he wouldn’t say anything?
Amelia can come here and pretty much confirm what I said in our whispers right now
Ok you seemed to be thinking that I couldn’t just say “Hey guys I’m librarian, I’m the real Amnesiac and PKR was a fake Amensiac”
If PKR ever came out as Lunatic, why couldn’t I have retracted the Librarian bluff and reveal the truth?
Nice try scum. Do you really believe that I think you’re that dumb? You would’ve done it more subtlety. Then again, there’s the possibility that you only did it as a ploy to gain everyone’s trust.
You know Amelia is right here and he could go through our whisper right now and confirm that I didn’t do anything subtlety scummy right?
Because do you really think people would’ve believed you after lynching him and the game not ending if he was evil? You also made several different claims too.
Yes…?
I literally have Amelia as my witness
He can confirm my entire Amnesiac thing from the very beginning
Also I’ve literally explained my several different claims
Well actually I’m pretty sure my two bluffs were Investigator into Librarian
I’ve already explained the Librarian bluff and my thinking with it
The Investigator bluff was really a simple RT.
Picked 2 names out of the 3 names I got and just sorta called them scum as a RT. Keep in mind this was before PKR claimed Amne to me in whispers