Blood on the Forums: Trouble Brewing [Good wins]

Philippines?

wrong

Marshal.
Read the danganronpa FM and tell me how much arete here and arete there match up.

Shurian has nominated Simon, and thatā€™s it. No other nominations so far.

Different here and there.

But these are different games and motivations

Arete is good and if we lose because youā€™re refusing to listen iā€™m going to slap you very hard

Iā€™m not convinced arete is town but Iā€™m gonna /hands up simon so that at least someone dies

ā€œItaly is confirmed minionā€
How far did that theory work?

You were counterclaimed and then switched your claim. And never softed to eevee that you were faking monk

Eevee openwolfed
In the end, I was right

Preeeeety sure eevee is still town here lmao.

Openwolving is honestly NAI here

1 Like

easy put my title as reader

Eevee was trying to trick me into making it look like arete would barely win while we voted in secret.
Not very 10/10 townie thing to do

/hands up Simon
I wonder why I never done this until now

If eevee is scum here then heā€™s been intentionally handicapping his own team, repeatedly, in order to give us a chance

so the question is how much I care about the openwolving

Also FWIW I donā€™t think we should be assuming that Wazza is telling the truth about his N1 target (I do think heā€™s probably legitimate Poisoner as per Possessed)

@Simon

can you explain to me why you donā€™t think Iā€™m the Demon? from the position youā€™re in and temporarily assuming youā€™re town I donā€™t see how you got to that conclusion

like itā€™s a correct conclusion but I donā€™t understand what town thought process would produce it

>_>

if we temporarily postulate an Eevee/Magnus/Wazza/Shurian scumteam, with Magnus as starting Demon, Wazza as Poisoner, Eevee as SW, and Shurian as Spy (I think this is basically the only scumteam compatible with W!Shurian and W!eevee), thenā€¦

ā€¦then Kyo and Simon, who under the given assumptions are both town, both received incorrect information N1

this is in fact technically possible, either if Wazza hit Kyo and Simon was under the influence of the Channel-master Fabled or if the reverse occurred

Maxwell/TL also received incorrect information in this world but it was incorrect in a way that would be compatible with him being healthy and sober (since Spy!Shurian could have registered as Good, in this case as Saint)

Kyo received incorrect info N2 as well in this world, but with Wazza not executed he could have been poisoned N2 (or he could be the channel-master-affected person)

in this world eevee would have had the entire rolelist (via Shurian). Which would therefore mean he intentionally had Magnus CC Isaac, and also intentionally had Wazza CC me? the first one is honestly weirder to me but I wouldnā€™t put ā€˜bus your Demonā€™ as completely outside of Eeveeā€™s scumrange

bussing your Demon and then starpassing the next night is admittedly a weirder strategy

this also explains the perfect kills, and potentially explains the thing with Italy ā€“ if eevee knew Italy was a fakeclaiming townie, he could have intentionally doubled up claims with him to get a mislynch, knowing that his claim was fake so that it wasnā€™t actually a conflict


I still think Simon!Demon makes more sense

eevee and Wazza didnā€™t feel W/W based on Wazzaā€™s treatment of eevee

the honest fundamental question is whether or not eeveeā€™s openwolving is legitimate

@Simon

why should I believe weā€™re living in the world I just outlined, and not the world where itā€™s just you?

@Shurian

why should I believe that itā€™s Simon and not you?