Blood on the Forums: Trouble Brewing [Good wins]

so possessed would rather die tonight and is faulting me for not seeing that point of veiw.

a very sound argument.

Iā€™d see an Undertaker alive while the other remaining classes arenā€™t to be pretty fake myself. Not to mention fake reveals can lead a court. Im saying if I live, I KNOW Iā€™m going to be executed. Im ok with it because when the game doesnā€™t end, my reveals should look even more legitimate.

I disagree.

hot take if Simon is Good: even if heā€™s Channel-Mastered or Drunk, then one of Italy and Magnus is likely to be evil

You faking that I should be hung tomorrow to make me survive isnā€™t knowledge a scum team doesnā€™t already have. Theyā€™d know the implications of my survival.

itā€™s clear WiFoM for whether you die, and I was trying to increase the WiFoM in the ā€œyou not dieā€ scenario while not actually increasing your lynch equity

Eh, last time I was Undertaker I lived to F3 after openclaiming D1 to bluff the Demon into thinking I was Ravenkeeper badly bluffing as Undertaker

ā€¦admittedly I was also the Drunk, though my N2 info was correct :eyes:

also we tricked the Demon into killing the actual Ravenkeeper and they picked the Imp

You answered your own questioning there lmao

can Hail reasonably be evil, let me work this out

if Hail is evil then thereā€™s no Drunk, which means the only possible sources of misinformation are poison and the Channel-master Fabled

give me a moment to work out the implications of this

a) I clearly didnā€™t think you should be hung tommorow if you live. So one person wasnā€™t convinced, and iā€™m sure im agreed with by more than a few nerds/

b) scum team donā€™t know what my intentions are for a lynch. They donā€™t know that i would fake deathtunnel you so that you could live. And so i was using that to my advantage

And I believe there is a guaranteed Fabled, correct?

Hail is pretty townie in my eyes.

the whole butler thing feels real to me

I think we have whoever hail mastered do an erratic vote pattern to see if hail actually butlered them

Its also a bad fake claim because too many Outsider claims and youā€™re caught.

1 Like

Hail just hasnā€™t been voting

which is a pretty legit way to play Butler not going to lie

Eevee is the monk.
Arete is the Mayor
Shurian is the Saint
Marshal is the Slayer
Director is the Butler
Simon is the Washerwoman. They found me or magnus as Investigator. (Which leads us to conclude Magnus is spy.)
Isaac is the Soldier
Maxwell is the Librarian. He confirms Shurian as the Saint.
Possessed is the Undertaker


there are 9/

who is the deaddie in this list again?

I can tell you now, if Iā€™m scum I have two potential night options. The obvious one is to kill the Undertaker and leave town blind; the other is to randomly kill someone and push on the Undertaker the next day. I already assumed that was gonna happen if I lived tomorrowā€¦wouldnā€™t need a tunnel because the tunnelers would out themselves.

Eevee

oh okay.

I donā€™t think we should discuss who the optimal nightkill is for the Demon because it just helps the Demon make an informed decision

obviously discussing nightkills from past nights is fine