Blood on the Forums: Trouble Brewing [Good wins]

Forum Matches Completed
#2885

oh I thought they’d whispered first

take that one off

#2886

whats ur poe arete

#2887

We can solve this with the “master weird vote thing” today

#2888

trust me when i say that accounting for every possibility is a misleading venture, especially in this game.
ive personally gone for it a number of times,

thats not how that works.
if you account for everypossibility you generally only find information which you already know, but in a different form. if you want a plan for the future you cant account for everything.it is the nature of plans. no plan survives contact with the enemy in a slightly complex scenario.

#2889

there are technically other possibilities, like ‘Maxwell was drunk/Poisoned and Shurian got lucky’ but I’m ignoring them at this point

#2890

id you want to be frank, its possible that the drunk thinks they’re the spy

#2891

but i dont think we should account for that possibility

#2892

no we can’t

Hail just hasn’t been voting, which is both compliant with the Butler rules and useless for proving things wrong

#2893

I don’t thknk that’s how it works

#2894

Drunk can’t think they’re evil or another outsider you nut

#2895

spy can be town.
drunk think they’re a town

#2896

I … think Simon might be right …

what the fuck

#2897

stuff like this is why you cant account for everything if you want to either make progress or keep your sanity

#2898

Hmm that would be pretty wack.

But I don’t think that’s the case here because wouldn’t they know each other at night?

#2899

angry and confused dialup noises

#2900

Arete do you claim spy?

1 Like
#2901

you have to go for the plan that accounts for the most things while still being viable
you have to strike a balance

#2902

my point here is that there are various obvious possibilities that Marshal is failing to account for

#2903

If arete is spy we move on.

#2904

I’m not the Spy and if I were the Spy you’d all be fucked