BotF IX - Call for Distress - Evil wins

Forum Matches Completed
#2241

Nominations, exiles and votes have been updated in the opening post. And yes, exiles are different from nominations in case anyone thinks I made a mistake separating exiles from nominations.

#2242

lmaooo
im not surpriseddd

me and intensify were commenting about how he was basically sitting around doing nothing
iā€™ll re-eval that read probably but
yeah

I also dont think Intensify/Eli are w/w

#2243

nuclear could theoretically be malfunctioning
but
iā€™ll look at eli and if they arent villagery then i think that theres no harm putting him next on the deck

#2244

weā€™re just having so many goddamn thunderdomes that its hilarious at this point

I dont think theres any harm in me personally assuming Atlas is Pixie purely by virtue of them claiming a fmpov demonstrably false check
i dont have any intention to convince anyone though

#2245

actually it probably is valuable to rand between me/pkr/eli because devils advocate almost certainly exists with the lack of pit-hagging that has been going on

#2246

gorta could have been pit-hag/devils advocate ig
definitely not boomdandy and probably not poisoner tho?

#2247

i think nuclearā€™s gorta result is

  • impossible to be sweethearted
  • very unlikely to be drunk
  • very unlikely to be sailorā€™d
  • from my point of view, anything that makes them not BH opens an entire can of worms with atlas
#2248

actually uh
i might rescind locking an execute on PKR
as the one who started the thunderdome, they have a plausable chance of being boomdandy
which uh
we probably dont want in this gamestate

#2249

does the demon know the alignments of all travelers?

#2250

Nuclear - Bounty Hunter - Gorta and Eli are Evil
Cloned - Amnesiac
Gorta - Fortune Teller - Eli and Silviu are not Demon
Pigeon - King
Atlas - Bounty Hunter - Gorta and Night are Evil
Leafia - Sweetheart
PKR - Tea Lady - Night is Evil
Night - Pacifist
Intensify - Lycanthrope - Wazza is Evil

so we have
Potentially V/V: (Poisoner, Pixie, etc.)
Intensify v Wazza
Nuclear v Eli
Atlas v Night
Atlas v Gorta (ONLY in a vacuum)

Unlikely V/V
Nuclear v Gorta
PKR v Night

#2251

is it just me or did i scroll through like half of Eliā€™s iso to find basically zero reads
not sure how typical this is in a BoTF but

its not really even super like, driven mechsolving
like i cant tell where he stands on a lot of stuff? not super socially wolfy but
not socially towny

my current stances are
Leafia likely Sweetheart
Nuclear likely BH
Atlas likely Pixie with possibility of Evil bluffing Pixie

Intensify lean Good, both poisoned and Evil!Wazza are plausible imo
Cloned lean Good (probably not w/w with PKR)
Pigeon slight lean Good
App slight lean Good

Silviu/Jane/Worse/Tangeld/Wazza Null

Zone slight lean Evil (weaker because, you know, not pinged by BH)

Eli lean Evil
Gorta likely Evil
PKR likely Evil and plausibly Boomdandy

#2252

i thought of something but im not going to say it

nya

#2253

You shouldā€™ve expected someone to ask when you said something that vague. What is it?

#2254

a thing about chances certain minion types are in the game w/r/t PKR as a possible boomdandy
the consequences might be worth sharing but its a thing id definitely need to evaluate at a non-midnight time

#2255

We do think of this sometimes

#2256

Also why is PKR likely evil?

#2257

Hi

This type of game really isnā€™t my forte, but Iā€™m assuming thereā€™s enough BotF nerds to explain whatever mechanics are prevalent at any time.

1 Like
#2258

Gorta got redchecked and now we are kind of waiting how to solve the game futher

#2259

Yeah, I saw. Iā€™ve read roughly the first 1300 posts of the game so far.

Did this get cleared up?

#2260

Hmm, Leafia doesnā€™t appear to be evil