i mean i liked the icibalus progression more
my thought on that is just that he thought “im going to go read some people” → “nobody is posting and idont wanna back read” → “ill check back later”
which requires conscious effort to fake as w
Her anger at Marshal feels real and Marshal just reeks of a wolf trying to push on Alice to find out her role. She can say all day that she doesn’t want Alice to claim, but that’s a lie because if she didn’t want Alice to claim, then she’d stop pushing for Alice to tell us why she doesn’t know when she’ll self resolve. I personally find it unlikely that Alice is truly self resolving, but I do think that she genuinely believes that she’s self resolving in a way that she can’t tell anyone without revealing her role. There’s also more players in this game than Alice right now, so why would a villager care if Alice really is self resoilving or not? Also, in the one group scum game with Alice that I had, she never acted like this. She didn’t even care if she was wolfread or not. I feel that if she was a wolf, she would’ve dropped the selfresolving claim a long time ago too especially with how Marshal is acting towards it.
Thus is like a mash it’s way more fun if u just read when ur online and then later iso top wagons and see if any are good
I’m not townreading Marshal.
idk i kinda wanna try this game because i like being a villager and this game is kinda easy tbh
could be playing BotF where 24 hours into day one we have an upwards of 10 mechanical conflicts
I don’t see why pointing out facts or genuine thoughts a wolf can have such as not wanting to backread requires conscious effort to fake as w
Hmmm, this is something I can understand honestly. Something I didn’t think of.
i mean it isnt really that strong of a read so 
i mostly feel like a wolf would be more likely to either actively want to make content, or not actively want to make content
idk id rather talk about the icibalus progression
Yeah, I could’ve tried explaining myself better.
also my thoughts probably still arent the most coherent because i havent entirely shaken off the fatigue i had earlier today
im not dry heaving anymore though which is good
(the reason i think this is because 3 minion games remove a lot of possibilities because if you find out “this minion is not in-play” then you can instantly find out all in-play minions.
also there’s only 4 out-of-play townsfolk by default, so you don’t have very many bluffs to go around.)
(and 1 minion games are kind of the opposite problem; if you find out the in-play minion, all other possibilities go away)
(2 minion games are the sweet spot; if you find 1 in-play minion, you know that minion is in play and that’s it. if you find 1 out-of-play minion, same thing. it still leaves lots of possibilities open, even when 1 minion is known.)
this isn’t the same thing as trying to get her to claim
i don’t think you should be townreading her for the anger because she can and does get frustrated like this as a wolf
i don’t really follow this
it’s a natural concern for a villager to check if a self-resolving claim is real especially since they usually aren’t and alice likes to do this a lot from what i’ve heard
ok this makes some sense
i feel like alice is confident enough to keep up the claim as a wolf, but yeah
I literally keep asking for examples of this and nobody ever gives me 'em.
This frustration’s from this site having no idea how to handle self-resolving claims.
I feel like Marshal/Yuno could easily be v/v and me and Zero just started with a villa read on the opposite player lol