Ciconia FM - Game Over - Order of the Public Bath Wins

Forum Matches Completed
#2410

Shurian
Nightingale
Vulgard
YunoGasai
Alkali

Prophylaxis r. Aelin
Wazza
Arctic r. Triplethree
WindwardAway
Atlas
Zerokito
min
clonedcheese
Galena
Hippolytus
Whysper r. Icibalus
Liattac
Luxy
Marluxion
Marshal
PokemonKidRyan
Rue
sulit
thepigeonnyc
EliThePsycho

Think Wazza is most likely town due to her emotional outbursts, townie reactions to getting pressured, and basically being constantly confused in spite of all of this. Don’t really see what type of agenda she’s pushing, and she’s been defending herself for basically the entire game.

Think Arctic and Windward are town because of others reads on them + they’re actively trying to solve. There’s a chance one of them is a wolf - we’ll cross that bridge when we come to it, but so far they’re pushing the game in a direction it desperately needs to go in.

Gonna trust the whole “Zero copped Atlas and has a village result” thing, even though I think both of their behavior is a little suspect (I’d appreciate it if Atlas wrote longer, more solvey posts rather than type one-liners all the time, and Zero is wasting time tunnelling and inciting someone who I believe to be town).

Also think min is likely town due to being involved in the game in a way that feels like they care, and I don’t really detect their maliciousness or any whiff of agenda from reading how they’re approaching the game. clonedcheese is probably the weakest of my townreads because of ~no solving but I think the way that they’ve fixated on their role reads as townie.

#2411

This isn’t really a thing to townread me for, I always have emotional outbursts btw

saying this before anyone else does

#2412

By emotional outbursts I meant mostly what I said re: the last post I made regarding how I was reading you.

Point taken, though.

Really want to focus on the half of the playerbase I didn’t color in, since I think there’s a decent shot there are some wolves in there. Haven’t read many of their posts though so gimme a sec.

#2413

@Arctic - when you get back to the thread:

Why do you believe that wolf sulit would try to avoid the two main villager wagons at eod1? do you think wolf sulit is the type of player to not want to put themselves on a town wagon so that they avoid the responsibility for it? I see your case on sulit but I’m not particularly convinced by that point.

can you talk to me about why marl, luxy, whysper, and marshal are on here?

ditto with all of the names on this list

do we know that an anticlaim/“soup” mechanic exists, besides the thing in the OP? i guess PKR’s oracle thing kind of confirms it as well but… eh.

#2414

i think anticlaim KP almost certainly exists and that if PKR is mafia he’s telling the truth about the anticlaim anyways 4 towncred

#2415

I dont think chloe ever claimed so its prob night KP as opposed to the dayvig that sniped alkaloe

#2416

im guessing its the blur thingy that sniped vulgard-san

#2417

is there a particular reason why we’re ignoring like

pigeon
whysper
PKR
Luxy
Marl?

ie, the slots that haven’t really done much of anything Today?

#2418

alright I’ve basically caught up with this Day

gonna try and take a crack at day 1 and do some hard analysis to finish off this friday

think there’s like, 6-8 slots in this game that are just going with the flow and I kind of want them to be pressured or die

i’ll try to ISO some of the POE slots, take a look at day 1 ISOs with zero context and hope some of it makes sense.

#2419

no ppl more or less brought those slots up im tryna talk about them but tbh i get distracted arguing with wazza or cheese or leafia or whoever to really actually PoE slots solidly.

I think the first 4 can die, I think marl is v likely town and how he’s handling the neighborhood and the paranoia surrounding it is villagery.

#2420

Can you point me to some posts that make you think he’s very likely town?

Did a quick skim of his ISO today and was pretty underwhelmed, though I know that I’m town, so him advocating to wagon me feels kinda blegh.

#2421

More specifically - his posts where he’s just latching onto the mechanics and just talking about them only reminds me a lot of his play in the Orangevitational game, where he just talked mechanics and we never wolfread him because of the Scientist check.

#2422

I think these are really villagery and not how a wolf would handle a neighborhood they control

because neighborhoods are a really good tool to pocket the game, he could strategically add people to maximally pocket villagers and put himself in towncore if he was wolf so pre-emptively shutting it off makes ~no sense from a wolf PoV

I liked a lot of his d1 if you want me to quote that too but that requires changing a thread and im lazy

1 Like
#2423

as wolf being security his mechanics handling was the opposite in where he hard pushed mechanics in his favor being contrarian to thread whereas he is putting himself at a mechanical disadvantage for what is seemingly no reason if wolf

#2424

possible it’s just WiFoM but i think wolves woulda given him cred for it at some point if this was the case and i havent seen anyone else bring this up which is kinda weird cuz its a pretty low-effort taking read

#2425

OK, I wasn’t aware that Marl controlled the neighbor chat. If he did then his posts regarding it make a fair amount more sense.

I’ll see if I can ISO his day 1, probably look at like these people too since they’re people in the PoE slot but not just actively lurking:

Galena
Hippo
Rue
sulit

#2426

Is a big claim needed for anticlaim? IDK how much of a claim constitutes being able to be anticlaimed.
I’m just going to say ‘yes’ and leave it at that.

#2427

Still like, kind of paranoid of you, Marshal (funny thing because the invitational being alted meant that I had no paranoia of you as Trapsetter) but I do appreciate you engaging with me.

#2428

I doubt it, but fair. I wouldn’t want to be at risk of getting shot and my rolecard blurred either

1 Like
#2429

yea its fair i think most people should be paranoid of me the best way to read me is off of results and i’ve really not gotten to have any results so I can understand not trusting me