(deleted) the brotherhood

[RopeStringFace]

(sorry, this post has been deleted to someone’s salt over it having the same name as one of his previous suggestions)

[RopeStringFace]

For those who are confused:

Dominus means master/owner in latin

Seniorem means elder in latin (according to google translate)

[Jazz]

Oh god I’m gonna have a field day with this

Will make post after I get out of College

[ThePlex]

Plus: https://forum.imperium42.com/t/faction-suggestion-the-brotherhood-w-classes/1826

[Jazz]

Main problems:

1. Limited Kills
2. Promotes gamethrowing for the BD
3. You seem to have put no effort in some of these ability names and that saddens me, also it makes me wary of the rest of the suggestion
4. You can become Knight and sell out your team
5. You have literally no reason to be told who are the royals and who is Neutral
6. I shouldn’t even have to explain why making people into mercenaries for no real reason is bad for the game
7. Two converting factions competing against one another, there’s a reason Cult was changed, y’know
8. You sacrifice yourself for the Dominus but straight up make the Seniorum Night Immune
9. The Seniorum becomes an observer because ???
10. Infinite meat shields
11. Has to defeat the Unseen but the Unseen can take you out Night 1

Minor Problems:
Being immune to Knight or Unseen convert isn’t a passive it’s just a thing that exists

[Hippolytus]

Hater

[Hippolytus]

Don’t let these punks get you down OP it’s alright.

[Hippolytus]

But yeah actually after properly reading it there are a LOT of issues

[Jazz]

Hate doesn’t factor into it at all, my dear boy

[Hippolytus]

She’s lying trust

[ThePlex]

I feel like a lot of this might have been copied from my Faction Suggestion…

[RopeStringFace]

@JammySplodge

1. Limited Kills

As soon as a new Dominus enters, they can kill again. Cult also has limited kills, so does mercenary. Its for a good reason; I don’t want the game to be very chaotic.

@JammySplodge

2. Promotes gamethrowing for the BD

How more so than the cult?

@JammySplodge

3. You seem to have put no effort in some of these ability names and that saddens me, also it makes me wary of the rest of the suggestion

Suggestions for ability names are appreciated.

@JammySplodge

4. You can become Knight and sell out your team

That’s the point

@JammySplodge

5. You have literally no reason to be told who are the royals and who is Neutral

The brotherhood cannot recruit royals, thus it is useful to know who they are. The brotherhood can make more informed kills with their limited killing ability with this knowledge.

@JammySplodge

6. I shouldn’t even have to explain why making people into mercenaries for no real reason is bad for the game

Reason: They devoted them self to the brotherhood, now that it is gone, they need something to do. It also provides other factions more desire to kill them, in hopes of getting a few mercs on them.

@JammySplodge

Two converting factions competing against one another, there’s a reason Cult was changed, y’know

This is why the brotherhood is severely limited in recruiting and killing capability. Think of being a brotherhood member as hard mode.

@JammySplodge

You sacrifice yourself for the Dominus but straight up make the Seniorum Night Immune

I wanted variability. I see no problems with the different abilities actually being altered.

@JammySplodge

The Seniorum becomes an observer because ???

The seniorum does not become an observer.

@JammySplodge

Infinite meat shields

Same for cult, seeing as any member can become cult leader. Also, it is not infinite, seeing as people have to agree to join.

@JammySplodge

11. Has to defeat the Unseen but the Unseen can take you out Night 1

same for reaper. Reaper is vulnerable to assassin N1, as they have no souls, and has to take out the unseen.

@JammySplodge

Being immune to Knight or Unseen convert isn’t a passive it’s just a thing that exists

I wanted to know how to make it clear they were convert immune

[RopeStringFace]

@ThePlex

Plus: https://forum.imperium42.com/t/faction-suggestion-the-brotherhood-w-classes/1826

These are completely different. Obviously, both cannot be put in
the game; if they were, one would have to change the name.

[SadSnake]

maybe the two brotherhoods are the brotherhood of x and the brotherhood of Y? i mean, they can still be brotherhoods, but with different names otherwise…

[ThePlex]

Well, for one, I was going to use mine in a future custom FoL, So go ahead and rename yours then

[ThePlex]

What’s the end goal anyway? You never specified.

[Jazz]

@RopeStringFace

Recruit (day, 2 uses): Offer a player a place in the brotherhood if the brotherhood has less than 2 brothers. An option select comes up the same it does when a mercenary offers a contract. If they accept, they become a brother. Royals cannot accept.

explain to me how this isn’t gamethrowing

[RopeStringFace]

@ThePlex

What’s the end goal anyway? You never specified.

@RopeStringFace

Goal: Kill or recruit all rivals (neutral killers, unseen, and blue dragon)

remember to reread the post if you are going to criticize.

[ThePlex]

I couldn’t find it in your un-organised heaps of text that are very hard to read

[RopeStringFace]

@JammySplodge

explain to me how this isn’t gamethrowing

If you really need an explanation, think of it this way: Player’s only have allegiance to them self. Thus, game throwing is doing something that you know will cause yourself to lose, not your faction. For example, it is not game throwing for the nobles to try and get converted, as the cult/unseen is significantly stronger with the nobles, and thus the noble might believe they have increased chances of winning if they attempt to get converted.