Eli’s take on PKR feels good-faith
I just disagree and think that from experience that townies are more likely to have progressions that are all over the place
This comes from how I make reads as villager and as wolf
as villager, I usually grip onto a point and talk about it, then spend a lot of time afterwards evaluating how strong that point actually is, while updating the thread continuously
as wolf, I usually take a point and stick to it throughout the day phase, through the bias of TMI or agenda
1 Like
I liked EFoL 4&3/4 - Game Thread- Day 1 (16/16) - #74 by SirDerpsAlot but other than that there’s not really much worth mentioning
I still think that post is enough to warrant a village lean, though probably not quite as large as I gave it
Min Jane
PKR Vulgard
CRich Derps
– Outer PoE –
Windward Eli
Marl
– Inner PoE –
Amelia Soulshade Wazza Eevee Geyde
Shurian (?)
There’s a relatively high chance that Shurian is a villager here, especially with only two wolves alive today but other than that feeling mostly good about this
Derps drifting down towards the Outer PoE line at this point in time tbh
Amelia like
feels fine tonally, and they’re talking about a bunch of mechanical stuff that I would be very uncomfortable and stilted talking about as a wolf
but I have no idea if that’s normal for Amelia, and I’m really unpracticed at that sort of stuff anyways
additionally, I still want to wait for them to provide content
also now I’m tied for top poster wowee
2 Likes
Anyway I’m thinking Jane is also likely a villager too.
- Jane/PKR interaction
Agreed I don’t think neutrals should become King unless they are clearly a BD siding neutral.
I have mentioned that I’ve mindmelded with Jane concerning PKR’s read on Derps and so does min as well.
- Jane interaction with Nightingale.
This is probably going to sound stupid, yet I don’t think it’s likely wolf!Nightingale makes this post.
The uncertainty expressed here seems hard to fake as a wolf.
Unless they are good at hiding TMI as lol!wolf, then this is either an uncertain villager or I just got pocketed hard. I’m going with the former.
Ok so I’m sure min is a villager here in this interaction, though I’ll have to look at Marl + windward to have a better idea what’s going on.
Probing Night’s thought process which looks villagery. So far so good.
I’m not sure if this take on Wind is correct, though I don’t think this comes across as wolf read in bad faith.
I can see why Jane thinks Night already had a wolf lean on Wind before making the post, though I don’t have any issue with Night’s progression so far.
Jane’s probing of Night looks very water fally and here their probing looks like it’s done with the objective of trying to solve.
Conclusion: I’d say Jane is probably a villager. Their thought process makes me think water fall which from what I’ve read is town AI.
The only people I see are Crich and Night… :3
Is Night a fairly experienced player? I’ll need that info to fairly slot them according to my level reading.
@Nightingale how long have you been playing FM?
I wont ask for games as meta reading is lulz
I’m treating Windward as a L1 for the time being seeing their ripness in other game
Aight uhh
Lemme get something then
Sort of
Given kinging it’s like
more important to make d2 reads but having a decent set of n1 actions is ~important
I would like to suggest something called mass claiming on day 1. I believe it is the penultimate form of villagery villageness in this haven of lies.
Mass claiming is the ultimate form of sniffing out wolves and finding villagers. No one will expect it coming, nor will they ever expect it coming, especially the wolves. The wolves will be so dumbfounded by this spectacular display of genius, that they will immediately put up a white flag.
The abundance of information that will allow the villagers to shift their attention immediately and instantly from boxing the wolves to who’s the liar. It brings into play which forumer would fake claim and therefore turns them into good lynches.
Lynches Prince Day 1
1 Like