EFoL 4&3/4 - Game Thread - Day 5 (5/16) - The Blue Dragon and Scorned are victorious!

[CRichard564]

@Nightingale

I just feel like they’re more likely to be a villager here for reasons already stated

It’s possible though as I said, not the most likely.

[Nightingale]

Eevee always needs to go here unless they start playing

[CRichard564]

This isn’t a bad idea as they’re in the PoE.

[Marluxion]

eevee needs to evolve into an Innocentchildeon or get released

[CRichard564]

It’s called posting yourself out of the PoE.

[CRichard564]

Here is my read list before I retire for the night.

Town Reads:
Myself, Geyde, Min, Jane and Nightingale

Town Leans:
PKR, SoulShade, Amelia, Marl, Eli, Wazza, Shurian

PoE:
Vulgard, Eevee, Derps and WindwardAway

[CRichard564]

Alright guess I’m off for real.
Good night everyone.

[min]

@Marluxion

i’ve posted roughly twice as much content as you

marl don’t even youve posted twice as many posts. not actual content

@Nightingale

update
Geyde is now ~good

Agreed

@Marluxion

i think people get the feeling that just because half of my posts are jokes means i haven’t given any actual thoughts when i most definitely have

You haven’t given as many thoughts as you’re claiming.

@Marluxion

just because you can’t tell what i’m thinking doesn’t mean i’m not thinking and paying attention

…show it then? If someone is saying you’re doing nothing, you’ve clearly not shone enough to be significant.

@Marluxion

also if i dont tow the line between scummy and towny i just get nightkilled or converted
ideally i shouldn’t even be posting at all today

I really don’t understand whatever this argument is? Simply just because conversion exists and night killing exists doesnt mean we don’t play the game. Idk, I could be really taking what I can do with my own role for granted to the point where I’m not so worried of either of those things but xddd. Regardless though, it’s not that hard to see the difference in how someone plays upon getting converted.

@Nightingale

Min Jane CRich
PKR Geyde Eli
Derps Shurian
– Outer PoE –
Vulgard
Marl
– Inner PoE –
Amelia Soulshade Wazza Eevee Windward - nul

Wazza is in there because I’m horrible at evaluating PR softs and don’t feel comfortable making reads about them

I kinda agree with these (make a few changes especially to towncore imo) but I’m worried that this like, too easy of a game and I already am paranoid we have a wolf in our little basedcore already. I obviously don’t know who it is despite that, so I’ll probably work alot on figuring out who that could be if it is the case. If this game just really is that easy then…wpwee!

@Nightingale

/vote Eevee
I don’t think anyone can contest this lul

I won’t contest but I have no idea how to read eevee so I’ll sheep everyone else on them eventually

@Marluxion

can i request you move windward out of the inner PoE into the outer PoE

Marl suddenly based

@Nightingale

I like windwards thread re-entrance at around 600 although I’ll probably make the real judgement for when I get to their reads
they can probably move up to Outer PoE again

again, we have 2 wolves and 14 non-wolves so having the entire game be villagery is nor-

Theres a scumsiding neut, so technically 2 wolves and a lost wolf. Also, the non scumsiding neuts are scarily not really the most fantastic town contributors maybe besides merc but shrug

I personally don’t like winds entrance if you’re talking about them saying they’re gonna make reads. The way they said they want to make themselves look like town doesn’t seem …? windy like at all.

@Marluxion

Fuck it, Marl.

@Nightingale

counterpoint
most of my D1 tells are tells based on presence of information which means the NE is moderately uncatchable
presence of agenda tells only really start to become viable in middle game

I like this post tbh. We should be focusing on finding the scum regardless before neutrals.

@Nightingale

Min Jane CRich
PKR Eli Marl
Derps Shurian Geyde
– Outer PoE –
Vulgard Windward

– Inner PoE –
Amelia* Soulshade Wazza* Eevee - null

*other players have expressed villa-reads on these people

The construction and the amount the poe is shrinking to me is worrying.

@PokemonKidRyan

Only things with attacks N1 as BD (Prince/Hunter)

@Marluxion

also if by villager you mean FUTURE KING, then correct

I want to become king to solely slim the chances of you being king but I won’t because I like my role.

@CRichard564

I have my reasons for thinking Marl, Wazza and Soul are more likely town than scum.

Explain the reasons?

@Nightingale

oops accidentally outed my whole team

I have no likes but I’m going to say I like this post.

@Marluxion

eevee needs to evolve into an Innocentchildeon or get released

I fucking cant why are you like the funniest person ever

@CRichard564

Alright guess I’m off for real.
Good night everyone.

Night crich

[PokemonKidRyan]

@min

I have no idea what this is supposed to mean.
But, I’m going to try to be helpful anyway.

I’m not wrong, am I?

[CRichard564]

@min

Explain the reasons?

I’ll quote the posts to save you time.

Town Reads:
Myself, Geyde, Min, Jane and Nightingale

Town Leans:
PKR, SoulShade, Amelia, Marl, Eli, Wazza, Shurian

Wazza Read:

PoE:
Vulgard, Eevee, Derps and WindwardAway

@CRichard564

@Wazza

Although, because I do want to be kinged tomorrow and this is totally not me saying this to bait wolves to kill me and this is also not a bait for me to bait wolves into not attacking me which is not a bait to bait to bait to bait.

anyway, in all seriousness, I will do stuff, give me like 5 mins

@Wazza

I want to be King because I want the power to kill whoever I want.

I mean…

…I can lead the town…
…I swear

Going through these 2 Wazza posts. I can see them softing as a Royal class as well.
Unless I’m horribly wrong here, I don’t think these posts should exist unless he randed a Royal class.

@Wazza

day 1 reads are useless because you’ll just hold onto them until night 1 and then forget about them only to remember them day 4, push using them and lose the game

Heavily disagree with this, as ahem we have a thing called updating reads.

@Wazza

Uhh…Anyway. I’m going to make the case on why I should be King today instead of what a normal person would do and make it tomorrow.

Another post which I don’t think should exist if they aren’t Royal.

@Wazza

No I don’t want to be King?

but I do

Ditto for this post.

Conclusion: Wazza has made the most obvious Royal softs I’ve ever seen so far.
If this is a cult game, then Wazza can only ever be a convert if evil and is obvious starting town.
If Unseen, then he might be be a Baron going for King play. Though that will depend on if Unseen get a convert N1.

@CRichard564

Even though Wazza doesn’t like D1 much, you can still make social reads which is the name of the game in Social Deduction.
Anyway onto Wazza. He put his hand up for King, which seems a little bold to come from a wolf.
I would think that if Wazza were a wolf, that they would be less overt in declaring they want to be King.
This might be a stupid take, though I like to think it’s a good take.

Marl Read:

@CRichard564

Marl defending Vulgard after the latter has been scum read seems a little weird to me.
I don’t it’s impossible for Town!Marl to be defending someone who is scummy, because their scum hunting skills aren’t the best I’ve seen.
For context in JoJo FM, he town read quite a few scum in that game.

@CRichard564

Thinking about it more. I wouldn’t be surprised if Marl is indeed a villager who thinks Vulgard is also a villager in danger of being misyeeted. Still I’d rather hear from Vulgard themselves why they are town if they are town.

SoulShade Read:

@CRichard564

@Soulshade55r

I’m ahead of the new meta.

Obs/Noble on me no one else.

Everyone else act scummy or if you act towny you will be voted tomorrow hard claiming prince

Ggs.

Hmm I don’t remember wolf!Soul making posts like this. They could be changing their playstyle, though this looks >rand v.

@Soulshade55r

Act scummy so you don’t get converted

A carefree joke, which doesn’t seem like something I’d expect from wolf.

@Soulshade55r

Vote me king I’m prince let major be prince I’m noob

This could be a D1 fake claim to bait the wolf night kill.

@Soulshade55r

Like I said obs and noble meta on me no joke I want no one to try day 1 so we can get non townie people smuggled into d2 without being killed or converted

Could be serious about this, though this could be coming from ToL experience.
We don’t have an NK who could do a mass kill, so it isn’t a terrible idea.

Conclusion: Soul is null slightly v lean.
Their posts come across as carefree and a little too bold to make as a wolf.
Snap D1 read.

Town Reads:
Myself, Geyde, Min, Jane and Nightingale

Town Leans:
PKR, SoulShade, Amelia, Marl, Eli, Wazza, Shurian

PoE:
Vulgard, Eevee, Derps and WindwardAway

[min]

@PokemonKidRyan

have no idea what this is supposed to mean.
But, I’m going to try to be helpful anyway.

I’m not wrong, am I?

No you’re not, I was being funny dw :]

[eevee]

Out of curiosity.

What’s your guys plan for this game?
Playing safe or playing aggressive?

[min]

Which of the two would you think I fall into?

[eevee]

I didn’t really care enough to read?

Besides it’s day 1 and I ask long term.

[min]

thanks for these ^^ I’m out of likes so Have verbal praise instead

[PokemonKidRyan]

I’m going to just be me.
Idk which you would count that is but…
“Playing PKR” I guess is the easiest cop out to say

[Jane]

I think my playstyle would be considered “playing safe”.

[CRichard564]

Lets see here. Case people and push them if needed.
Probably more on the aggressive side.
Anyway I need sleep.

[CRichard564]

@Marluxion

eevee needs to evolve into an Innocentchildeon or get released

Everyone we have our in game comedian.

[CRichard564]

Stay tuned for the next Marl FM joke.