Ici, pretty sure you misread what Solic meant, regardless of his alignment this game.
Oh sure, let me form a non-consensus counterwagon of a supermajority of 14 votes, I’m sure that’s going to work. You’re basically ensuring that no lynch can happen without the wolves’ consent.
I want to choose mountdoom because I am interested in information it provides us And totally not because I want to turn voting phase into a meme
2 Likes
But it literally does provide a shit ton of information. Forcing everybody to vote their highest villageread and convince somebody to vote with them is neccecarily a ton of information, because it forces far more active positive consensus-building from villa and forces incorrect play from wolves.
1 Like
It’s better for people to vote villagereads with one or more other people. See? We’re disagreeing about the very methodology of how we should vote. Tell me that won’t make interesting arguments and thus provide information.
On second thought, it’s unlikely we will get a scum lynch on Mount Doom anyway. It should be easy enough for scum to propel wagons on scum to a higher amount of votes so a town gets lynched instead.
It does provide information for later though, especially when more flips happen.
Icibalus we both know what is going to happen with this map being chosen and it’s not going to be good. Your argument about information being gained is USELESS when this map always helps wolves in the first place.
First off, we can never lynch a wolf with this map. It’s practically impossible, the wolfest player can literally vote an innocent child and kill them. It’s an awful idea.
Second of all, forcing villagers to use their kills is a BAD IDEA. It’s like forcing a villager to make up a scumread out of the blue, I don’t trust a 1/3 of this playerlist to actually shoot scum if they were forced to shoot someone. As well as the fact that what you mentioned earlier, claim vigilantes, are likely infinite use and therefore forcing them to use it does absolutely nothing.
2 Likes
that we could have lynched D1. It’s like relying on a red check before you lynch someone.
This feels like an argument over whether information or a scum lynch D1 is better.
I think a scum lynch is always better especially in a game this size so I’m reconsidering M o u n t D o o m.
I would like to point out that we are not gaurented to lynch a villager, because the wolves have to vote for consenus villagereads because voting for their partners is risky from their perspective.