That’s bullshit reasoning marshal
How are you not seeing that Astand is scummy
Literally Astand’s entire Iso is a trainwreck
The only people who are townreading Astand are the ones who are sheeping Alice and Alice is scummy as all hell
Marshal if you think Vulgard is scum feel free to point out how Vulgard didn’t contracdit himself like I said he did
No it isn’t, I gave examples of why he’s scum. You just said he was town and called my reasoning bullshit.
1 Like
thats a different argument than the one we’re having here. we can have that argument, but its not this one here.
alice will most likely be dead by the end of tomorrow anyways, either from targeting a town or by claimvig. so as long as we get something good out of her its fine, as thats about as much as we can expect from her, not counting reads.
1 Like
so marshal,
what has alice done in particular that is scummy to you
and what has vulgard done that is townie
1 Like
The penalty for hitting town with lynch is town dead
The penalty for hitting town with alice is a confirmed vul and town dead
the bonus for hitting scum with lynch is scum dead
the bonus for hitting scum with alice is confirmed alice and dead scum.
alice trying(and possibly succeding) to kill vul resolves ALL of this. and frees up lynch
I literally added in boss and my reasoning is still better then yours. You don’t explain why he’s town. You explain why we should shoot someone, literally just shooting someone. And I agree, that’s why she should shoot boss and then we lynch Vulgard
You know what? I think vul has a chance of being scum.
And also I said that i TR alice.
but i think vul vs. alice has high TvS potential, and I want it to be resolved that way
Your evidence on Vul being scum is literally ‘he contradicted himself once on his read on Icibalus.’ Vul and I have mindmelded here way too many times for him to be scum, and he’s being pushed by basically my top scumread, who’s scumreading him basically on the grounds that she did something INCREDIBLY SCUMMY and he pointed out how scummy it was
He’s being too bullheaded and even now saying Vulgard is probably scum but we should not lynch him
trying to make him seem better if Vulgard dies
That is not defeating my point for his contradiction, second off all I pointed out other contradiction and his stances on people this game.
vul and alice are much more likely different teams than boss and alice.
and boss is individually more likely to be scum than either
we can resolve vul vs. alice and kill boss