[FM] Lord of the Rings Forum Mafia - (7/25) - Completed - Mafia Wins!

not to mention a lynch needs a scummy target much more than her vig target, since that works on scum and town

Did I say lynch them right away? No I did not. I said we should always lynch him today. Tomorrow is today’s yesterday.

1 Like

If Inexpliably Town Alice gets redirected then either she hits a townsperson, dies, and confirms herself, thereby confirming there was a redirect, or hits a scum, kills the scum, and there’s an unexplained kill on scum

Vul isn’t garunteed scum, but will die tonight if they are.

wouldn’t you rather lynch a non-vul scum and have vul die tonight then lynch vul and have alice get claimvigged tommorow?

today is tomorrow’s yesterday* i think

1 Like

Arete NO one confirms that Alice is redirected because she will just die and everyone thinks Vulgard is confirmed.

Vulgard contradicyed himself so many times we need to just lynch him

Oh that’s it

either way, scum vul dies, but in the night case, it confirms alice and gives us time to use the lynch better

I thought she said that when she hits town said town get modpeeked as such, am I misremembering that?

no
it makes more sense to lynch someone whos scummier, vul or not
if you can propose someone scummier than vul, they can be lynched instead
but as long as vul is the scummiest we’ll put them on the lynch

1 Like

Vulgard is near guartaeed to be scum based on how they acted today, Alice can shoot someone else and confirm themselves as town or the person they shoot as town.

Nothing is different here besides lynching the more scummy person

If she shoots boss and he’s scum he dies and it confirms Alice and gives us time to lynch Vulgard who is also scum

who says it has to be vul to confirm alice
and atm vul is the best use of the lynch

1 Like

oh dang is this my first mindmeld

1 Like

a) I do not think vulgard is scum here.

b) if you really want the minimal chance of alice dying, you use it on the scummiest and lynch someone else.

Simon I don’t think we ever agreed on something before

1 Like

Alice is scummier than Vul though

and Astand is scummier than Vul and almost as scummy as Alice

If you didn’t think they were scum why do you want Alice to shoot them

Yeah but we can’t lynch Alice can we if we want this to work and Astand isn’t scummy

becuase it resolves this whole fucking thing.