[FM] Lord of the Rings Forum Mafia - (7/25) - Completed - Mafia Wins!

I want that nap right about now. See you guys later.

giphy%20(6)

Well i have to do like 3-4 hours of homework so see y’all then

what about the possibility that she isnt lying?

Leaning towards newbscum here. Your Iso has a distinct lack of strong stances and most of your reads are both weak (in the sense that you don’t want to take a strong stance) and relatively uncontroversial (which indicates to me that you’re trying to blend in, which is really common among newbscum).

What are your thoughts on Astand?

its a message, in general.
i believe that counts as codes

oh welp nvm then

or rather, for the clarity of this post, a hidden message that can then be revealed later

We are not waiting for Alice to shoot Vulgard tonight. We are lynching him today. Alice should shoot Boss/Kai depending on how Vulgard flips here which should always be mafia.

Look at Vulgard posting before. They have been starting wagons on different people while trying to throw shade on the people everyone else is voting. I don’t think it’s an coindenice that they did this.

Second of all, Vulgard is trying to bullshit his Icibalus read. He said before that he scumread Alice, however when I confronted him about his readlist saying Icibalus was town he switched gears and said that it was a test to see who would jump on the Icibalus train. However he contradicted himself because if it was really a test he would have dropped it when he switched votes, his reasoning on keeping it to see who scumreads Icibalus makes zero sense because then it would punish people who scumread him for no reason, it doesn’t make sense.

Finally, as crazy as it sounds there’s a possibility that this is scum theater between them. Vulgard is acting super obvious scum right now meaning we should lynch him, however if Alice can’t shoot someone else then we caught scum trying to confirm the other by this whole nonsense.

He even said stop defending your scum partner to a person he said was town himself, which means he contradicted himself again.

why can’t this resolve tonight?

Also the fact that if we rely on mechanics to have Vulgard dead, a whole bunch of things can go wrong. Vulgard can get healed, Alice can get redirected to someone else, ect.

Because reads>Mechanics

If Alice is somehow telling the truth and gets redirected doesn’t that basically out Vulgard as scum? and since she’d either die or kill a scum, she’d be confirmed.

I strongly disagree.

we will 100% catch a scum tonight and confirm a town or confirm a town

why risk that for a distrust?

If they get redirected who is going to know they were redirected? No one besides Vulgard.

I swear to God if Alice is somehow town here I’m hanging up my metaphorical Forum Mafia hat in shame or however the expression goes

they’d probably redirect her to somone less worthy, which doesnt mean squat on vulgard on its own

because we will lynch anyone anyways and I’ll rather lynch the person that’s scummy

Lynching scum guarantees their death while shooting doesn’t.

I would rather use this time to gain info and relationships and use the night to resolve that issue