Yeah, Ici has a high chance of being one of them, especially with his ‘townread’ on Alice either yesterday or today. The rest, I’m not so sure
Ah right, I remember that read. It was kinda unfounded, considering Andrej had posted little to no reasoning for his reads and at some points seemed to be picking targets at random. There’s no way a locktown would be a justified read, unless Andrej is such a chronic slacker as scum that even a little activity is enough to make him look town. Again, I can’t give deeper commentary on meta reads since I don’t know the meta. Ignoring meta as I currently have to when making independent reads, I’d say this was an attempt to give Andrej towncred since Dat was initially quite high in many of our townreads.
While I understand the point, I don’t think reads supported (or in my opinion at the time) at least by walls and ISOs that turn out wrong are exactly comparable to almost random not even barebones reads. I think I got Solic wrong because of a lack of meta knowledge: he seemed super scummy in his reads in conjunction with his interactions with Kai, but that was apparently normal for his town game.
Andrej’s reads are almost entirely unsupported by reasoning and/of evidence. Now, I don’t have a comprehensive knowledge of newb behaviour either since I am a newb. With that said, under my current interpretations, I am confident that he is scum.
Despite that, I am happy with hearing more from those townreading him, since I’m unable to give a fully meta-informed read at this time.
On mobile again and quotes are bad 
Also help I have been watching Undertale songs I blame Icibalus
He was being scumread at the point when he posted the wall, though, it wasn’t likely to give him much in the way of towncred. Do you think Datbird would be so obvious as to make his slanker scumbud his second highest townread?
It doesn’t change it by that much with him showing little interest in the game so far
Kind of reminds me of Marl and his scumtell
I don’t know what the difference in posting style between an experienced inactive and a newb inactive is, so I have no way of knowing.
Well I can give you the answer he’s a new person, do you think a new person knows how to read people correctly right away?
Marl’s meta was that if he was scum, he wouldn’t get invested in the game and do very little. He wouldn’t be helpful, but instead, he’d just sit there
Why would you be so hard on andrej, in his literal first game?
You also failed a scumread(solic) so why be so harsh on him?
Dat did make the ultimate mistake of flavourclaiming accidentally, so I’d say that it’s definitely possible that he’d make other less than advisable moves.