Fits in with the fact that Hippo claimed to have been on a shaky train earlier.
Occam’s Razor states that this is the reason behind his typo.
Also worth noting. No proper defense in the morning. Hence odds of Hippo thinking I am traitor and signaling go up immensely.
Math, the thing is that you went from “the post about chess is a reference to a previous game” to “ici and I were both wolves that game” to “ici thinks i’m lost wolf and is singalling to me” to “HIPPO ALSO ‘SIGNALLED’ TO ME EARLIER, AND I THINK HIPPO IS A WOLF FOR SOME REASON” to “SOMEBODY HAS TO HAVE SIGNALLED LOST WOLF TO ME!”.
A series of logical leaps that are almost gaurenteed to end in you finding out that PKR actually signalled lost wolf to you and the real wolves were the friends you made along the way.
There’s a difference between making wild theories and making wild theories that have a >1% chance of being correct.
Correction.
I have noticed that Hippo bit for a while and didn’t say anything. I wanted to see how others reacted.
If we lynched outside the wagon I would want to lynch HTM and if Htm flipped scum lynch Hippo.
I really don’t like the general consensus with me being V and Blue being W here, especially considering that the thread flow completely glossed over when I raised this point.
The only dissidents here were Kai who slipped as V d1 and James who is doing god fuck knows in the thread. The entire way that the day has gone by points to the wolves being somewhat satisfied with this outcome, tbh.
However I also feel really bad about Ici for similar reasons because I don’t see Ici telling me to play chess if he thinks my reads are wrong and/or I am scum
Math, it was a joke. I was trying to imply “gee, wouldn’t it be funny if Math did a terrible signal to LT and it all went disasterously wrong”.
i may sound overdefensive but I really fucking hate it when people take shit out of context to back up their absurd theories. Let me calm down for a few minutes.
A joke after a post in which you hard read Lady as town and then say Blue scum is not a read, yet when your Blue scum is dependent upon a Lady read, ergo if you’re town is a read.
Hence the contradiction and I was suggesting to Lady to check you. However it seems she has no interest in that.
It’s not a read if it’s not based on a series of reasonings based off a person’s posts directly and is instead based on mechanical information provided by another person. That’s called a red check.
Unless you have it, that’s always a read because you make a judgment call about the thunderdome
Mainly if we assume Lady is town I think she should check Htm, Ici, or Hippo
Was too much weirdness here.
sigh We have different definitions about the nature of a read. Could you do me a favour and not wolfread me for it?
Anyway, could you reexamine your Hippo read for me? Just assume that I know what I’m talking about and figure out if If my points about good tone + the general implausibility of wolf!Hippo in general hold water or if I’m just being too lazy to spot the “obvious wolftells” that you can see.
Btw of the two Lady is more than likely telling the truth based on this. If Blue has redirected Lady and Lady was town then she outs redirected not guilty.
So TvT is officially out.
If Blue is town then Lady is 100% scum here unless someone can provide a reason for a blue frame which I find unlikely
What do you think I am doing asking all these questions? I am trying to reanalyze the game.
Regardless of who was on his Wagon I didn’t like any of the reasoning behind it and I stand by that. I had him as pretty bang on Null at that point and too many people were happy with voting him up.
Then he suggested that I was trying to role-fish him even though I was soft-defending him. Scum HTM would NEVER discredit someone stopping their lynch, like never. So he moved to a soft town-read for me.
As regards to your wagonimics stuff I don’t know. I don’t think you can really conclude if scum were or weren’t on his wagon but it is odd if Htm is town (which I still think is most likely) and there was no scum on it. Magnus would be most likely scum on his wagon in that case.
As to the “htm may be traitor” I don’t see that at all, a traitors wagon moves in the same way as townies wagon so I don’t see how that can be discerned. He could be traitor due to his flippfloppy nature like Thamasa said, but again Htm is just floppy in general.