FM - Unknown (Town Victory!)

Forum Matches
#21

Fool/Jester is bastard

#22

It’s not though.
If you think it is and have a problem with the descriptions, you don’t need to play :man_shrugging:

#23

It is

1 Like
#24

/Unjoin
I’m taking a break actually.
I’ve had enough of this place recently

#25

Btw
I cant think of a 3 non bastard neutrals
Jester(for marl) , survivor and sk?

#26

It literally is though

It punishes the Town for a correct lynch

That is inherently bastard

#27

Jester is not a correct lynch though.
Unless you’re saying all neutrals should be lynched.
Which is factually incorrect.
After all, why have a specific neutral killer which we specifically need to kill if we’re supposed to kill all neuts?

5 Likes
#28

You aren’t required to kill all Neutrals

But Neutrals are just that

Neutral

They are not on your side

Lynching them is lynching somebody not on your side

#29

A Jester is an incorrect Lynch by definition.

1 Like
#30

/join

#31

yes but that does not mean lynching a neutral necessarily counts as a ‘correct’ lynch

1 Like
#32

like when an alch is only helping you and you have reason to believe they will keep helping you even if it might be a bit better for them to swap to scum.
you are effectively losing an ally by lynching them

1 Like
#33

My point is proven.
Therefore Marl was correct.
To Ici (And Orange) Fool/Jester, Scorned/Executioner are all non-bastard

1 Like
#34

Non-Town-aligned roles are inherently not incorrect lynches

1 Like
#35
1 Like
#36

They are by definition not inherently correct lynches and as a result of something being not correct. It must be incorrect

#37

Scorned/Executioner aren’t bastard and never were considered to be

#38

Rather, as they are not incorrect, they are able to be considered “correct”, for game terms.

#39

Jester is not Bastard, IMO. Regardless, there is no Jester in this setup.

2 Likes
#40

Your opinion may not be provably wrong

But I’ll side with the wisdom of countless long-time Mafia players in this case :stuck_out_tongue: